17 OCTOBER 1931

Page 1

News of the Week

The Spectator

The Election T HE stage is set and with very few exceptions the actors are allotted their parts. In very few con- stituencies are the candidates not finally chosen when we...

The most flagrant example of an association putting party before

The Spectator

country in the constituency is at Darwen. No constituency should be ashamed of being repre- sented by a member with a long record so distinguished as that of Sir Herbert Samuel....

We deal in our leading articles with the manifestoes of

The Spectator

the Prime Minister, Mr. Baldwin and the National Liberals. There are points of difference which made it impossible for all to sign one document. But there is agreement enough,...

[Signed articles do not necessarily represent the views of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.]

EDITORIAL AND PUBLISHING OFFICES : 99 Gower Street, London, W

The Spectator

.C; 1.—A Subscription to the SPECTATOR costs Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the world. The SPECTATOR is registered as a Newspaper. The Postage on...

But we must take their utterances seriously, and their silences,

The Spectator

too ; and- these drive us to oppose them and to beg the electorate to return the National Govern- ment to power with a stronger majority than before the dissolution, and to...

Page 2

The Round Table Conference The Prime Minister, on October 8th,

The Spectator

attended the Minorities Committee of the Indian Round Table Con- ference, and expressed in the plainest terms his disap- pointment at the Committee's failure to agree on the...

Manchuria The Council of the League of Nations was summoned

The Spectator

to meet on . Tuesday for the consideration of the very grave situation in Manchuria. Lord Reading made his first appearance at Geneva as our Foreign Secretary, and M. Briand...

We do not accept these statements of accusation and defence

The Spectator

as necessarily well founded. Indeed, we. do not see how the Chinese delegate at Geneva can be expected to produce accurate information. There is no doubt about the extreme...

To judge impartially the wrong entailed by contests between supporters

The Spectator

of the Government, we might imagine Unionists contesting at Seaham and Derby the seats of Mr. MacDonald and Mr. Thomas. Such opposition would only be extreme examples of the...

- • • * * *• * The Federal Structure

The Spectator

Committee of the Conference has been sitting again this week with Lord Sankey in the Chair, and has been chiefly concerned with finance. In the separate Round Table Conference...

We cannot possibly summarise all the political speeches of the

The Spectator

leaders, but it would be a mistake to think that they cancel one another out. The aggregate reasoning on behalf of the National Government is overwhelming. The Prime Minister's...

Page 3

The President sought the views of the Congress leaders on

The Spectator

the larger questions of international finance. At the close of this month the French Premier, M. Laval, is to visit Washington. He will undoubtedly raise the ques- tion of...

* * * * The German Situation Dr. Bruning, the

The Spectator

German Chancellor, has formed a new ministry and is exercising the dictatorial powers conferred by the President's decree last week. He faced the Reichstag with apparent...

Spain The Cortes in Madrid decided by a large majority

The Spectator

on Tuesday that Church and State should be separated in Spain. " There shall be no State religion." That may mean much or little. Religion is a personal matter of the spirit. If...

Two Academicians The Royal Academy, while mourning the death of

The Spectator

Sir William Orpen, has lost two more popular and dis- tinguished members in Mr. Charles Ricketts and Sir Bertram Mackennal. Mr. Ricketts, who was sixty-five, was one of the most...

Sir John Monash We regret to record the death, on

The Spectator

October 8th, of General Sir John Monash, who commanded the Australian Corps in France during the last year of the War. Sir John, who was born in Melbourne sixty-six years ago,...

Bank Rate 6 per cent., changed from 4k per cent.

The Spectator

on September 21st, 1931. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on Wednesday 961; on Wednesday week, 97k ; a year ago, 1041. Funding Loan (4 per cent.) was on Wednesday 831 ; on Wednesday...

President Hoover's Plans • President Hoover last week held an

The Spectator

important con- ference: with the leaders of both parties in' the United States Congress to consider the financial crisis and to devise means for restoring public confidence...

Page 4

The Nation and Parties

The Spectator

OUR political leaders have sent forth a shower of Appeals and Manifestos to water the earth from which they hope a harvest of favourable votes will spring. We take for granted...

Page 5

The Hesitating Voter

The Spectator

" E VERYTHING in England," wrote a well-informed observer returning from abroad a fortnight before the General Election was announced, " is uncer- tainty and confusion." It...

Page 6

The Two Presidents

The Spectator

P RESIDENT Hoover and President von Hindenburg arc sharing for the moment the heaviest responsi- bilities in the world crisis. It is a pity, from the inter- national standpoint,...

Page 7

How to Right the Trade Balance

The Spectator

BY SIR ARTHUR STEEL:AIAITLAND. [Next week Mr. Lionel Robbins, of the London School of Economics, will write on the same subject.] T HE need for the restoration of our trade...

Page 8

Economy and the Building Industry By MURRAY LESLIE.

The Spectator

N O industry seems likely to go through a more lean time as a result of economy proposals than the building trade. In the last few weeks there has been a number of actual or...

Page 9

Problems of the Christian Conscience

The Spectator

I We publish below the second article of a new Theological Series, which we hope will throw light on some of the Most disputed ques- tions of conduct. Mr. Christopher Dawson is...

Page 10

On being a Water-Diviner

The Spectator

BY PETER FLEMING. I CONFESS that I had always treated water-diviners as a joke. The humour that (God forgive me I) I saw in their profession was not the rich, full-blooded...

What Individuals Can Do for Peace—II

The Spectator

T HE delegates who will be sent by Governments to Geneva for the Disarmament Conference next February will not be able to swing the opinion of the world to this side or that, or...

Page 11

* * * OMNIBUS INSULTS.

The Spectator

Ingenious and generous publishers are steadily popularising the " omnibus " volume which packs between covers two or more novels by one or more writers. Was not the Forsyte Saga...

As The World Goes

The Spectator

GESTURES OF ECONOMY A regiment of Guards has marked the epoch of patriotic economy by marching, amidst popular applause, from Aldershot to Windsor. This fine gesture has...

* * * * Last week's International Shoe and Leather

The Spectator

Fair has con- vinced exhibitors that women's feet are not larger than they used to be, but merely that women are no longer ashamed of large feet. I believe this, since I heard...

* * * *

The Spectator

WHAT TO RENOUNCE. It was suggested, the other day, that almost the only way of harming oneself, without hurting anybody else, is to refuse to take a pension one doesn't need. A...

AS to pensions. It is rumoured that many patriots have

The Spectator

already written to the Pensions Office renouncing theirs, or bits of them. These letters must make a refreshing change for the officials who are accustomed to the other or com-...

frequent phrase : " it ought to be possible." It

The Spectator

annoys him. I sympathize. But we know what it means. There are other, less intelligible offenders. I should like to select one or two of the commonest, each week. At the moment...

NEXT WEEK : The SPECTATOR interviews .Mr. Gandhi.

The Spectator

In spite of a proclaimed national unity, we have to

The Spectator

face weeks of political oratory. For the orators' sakes I urge newspaper proof-readers to watch for misprints in the speeches of the candidates they support. For one descends so...

Page 12

Art

The Spectator

The London Group and Others To the observer, familiar with past exhibitions of the London Group, perhaps the most striking aspect of the twenty-ninth exhibition, which is being...

The Theatre

The Spectator

" The Anatomist." By James Bridie. At the Westminster Theatre.—" Vile Bodies." Adapted from Evelyn Waugh's novel by Arthur Boscastle. At the Arts Theatre Club. Da. BRIDIE has...

Page 13

* * * * THE WRONG TREES.

The Spectator

It was said at one time that the substitution of the aero- plane for the ship had changed the scenery of England. There was this much truth in that hyperbole : the Crown (now a...

* * BRITISH Bolas.

The Spectator

Since some brief suggestions were issued last week in this place for the purchase of British_ bulbs, with congratulations to those Wisbech firms who have begun to send out...

* * * * ROAD-LOVING BIRDS.

The Spectator

A tirade against the motor-car and new highways as cruel enemies to bird life has appeared in the quarterly journal—. alarays a very suggestive productioa—of the R.S.P.B. Pro-...

The district is well worth a visit from motorists or

The Spectator

other voyagers, expecially if they have any interest in farming. Some of the best intensive farming in the world, by large as well as small husbandmen is to be seen over these...

* * * * ECCENTRIC PHENOMENA.

The Spectator

The superlative is generally a mendacity ; but does one tamper with truth in suggesting that the . eccentricities of this season are beyond parallel? And. they have appeared in...

In my own experience—which may be accidental, not symptomatic—the number

The Spectator

of oddly coloured birds has been quite unusual. I have heard of albinos in many species, in many places ; and this week on the South Coast came upon the haunt of a black snipe,...

Country Life

The Spectator

WHERE THE PRESERVERS MEET. Few places in England could be better suited than Bath for the annual meeting of the Council for the Preservation of Rural England. The town itself...

Page 14

CANADA AND THE GOLD STANDARD

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—In your issue of October 3rd, and in your article on " The Prospects of the Election," you say, " and at thi s moment there is less need...

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

[In view of the length of many of the letters which we receive, we would remind correspondents that we often cannot give space for long letters and that short ones are generally...

"ECONOMIC v. ARTIFICIAL"

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—It is rather difficult to understand your financial editor's application of the terms " economic " to the conditions imposed by the "...

THE WORKERS' STANDARD OF LIVING

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —The arguments based on the standard of living being so much in evidence in the objections urged by the Opposition to the economies...

ECONOMY AND THE ENGINEER

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—The effect of the present Economy Campaign as regards Public Works is now beginning to appear. It is clear that the Government have in...

Page 15

THE WEEKLY BANK RETURN

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—In view of the changed condition of affairs, and although the " Bank's " liability to redeem its notes in gold is merely suspended, it...

THE IDEAL TARIFF

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Will you allow a quite undistinguished, and, therefore perhaps typical, man to say what he thinks on this question ? It seems to me that...

THE NEED FOR SPIRITUAL RENEWAL

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sra,—Those of us who are aware in a vague way of new lines of thought opening out before us as the result of various dis- coveries in...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —General Smuts, in his

The Spectator

Presidential address to the British Association has, it seems to me, diagnosed the world's sickness. Near the end of his enthralling survey of the great achieve- ments of...

Page 16

MIXED MARRIAGES AND THE COLOUR BAR

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —Your article of July 18th, under the above caption is very interesting, but perhaps an examination of actual results of mixed marriages...

CASTE IN INDIA

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sni,—Sir Harcourt Butler and the writer of the review of " India Insistent," in your issue of October 3rd, do not agree as to the rate at which...

THE ROUND TABLE CONFERENCE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—We should all be very sorry if the Round Table Con- ference broke down over the communal difficulty. Per- sonally, I have always thought...

Page 17

WORLD HELP FOR CHINA

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIE,—In an article on Manchuria in your issue of Septem- ber 26th, you write: " If, by some form of international co-operation, the Powers...

THE GALLOWAY HYDRO-ELECTRIC SCHEME

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—I understand that powers have been conferred, under the Galloway Water Power Act, 1929 (19 & 20 Geo. V. C. lx-s.-x.), incorporating the...

THE POLYGAMOUS PARTRIDGE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—In your " Country Notes " of September 12th Sir W. Beach Thomas writes : " A theory has been started that the partridge is on occasion...

R.S.P.C.A. AND HUNTING

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SrEcrxrcut.1 should like to endorse Mr. Binstead's views as to stag hunting, and quite agree that the subject is better left alone. As a land agent of some...

Page 18

ANTI-REFORM POTATOES.

The Spectator

In consequence of the Earl of Mansfield's opposition to the Reform Bill, many of the inhabitants of Highgate and Hampstead have declared they will not eat the potatoes grown...

THE STATE OF LONDON.

The Spectator

Nothing can exceed, considering the greatness of the public disappointment, the quiet which has prevailed in London during the whole of the week. On Monday there was a very...

THE LATE PROFESSOR VON .WILAMOWITZ- MOELLENDORFF [To the Editor of

The Spectator

the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—By the death of Ulrich von Wilamowitz-Moellendorff Europe has lost her most distinguished Greek scholar. There was nobody quite like him : he was not only...

_ THE LATE CECIL SHARP.

The Spectator

At the request of his executrix I am writing the Life of Cecil Sharp, and I should be grateful if those who knew hint would send me any letters that they may have from him, or...

POINTS FROM LETTERS TITHE BARNs.

The Spectator

We know of an old tithe barn in North Hampshire. It was the tithe barn of Crondall Parish, before that parish was sub- divided. It stands in the grounds of " Peatmoor," Fleet,...

THE HISTORICAL MSS. OF CEYLON • [To the Editor of

The Spectator

the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—The Government of Ceylon has recently appointed .a Commission for the purpose of inquiring into the existence of hitherto unknown documents relating to the...

Poetry

The Spectator

O ut in the Woods. . . . October CowcaoFr Woods are green yet, For oaks are late in turning ; But the copses up at Hunridge, Of beech, are slowly burning To leaflessness...

A Hundred Years Ago

The Spectator

At the last Levee but one, his Majesty, with much affability, - inquired of Prince Talleyrand as to the state of his health ? The veteran diplomatist replied that he " was...

DRURY LANE THEATRE.

The Spectator

On Thursday evening, Mr. Macready repeated his part of William Tell ; a character, as our readers know, of the same cast as Virginias, Alfred, &c., and of which he is a spirited...

Page 19

"Spectator" Competitions

The Spectator

RULES AND CONDITIONS Entries must be typed or very clearly written qn one side of the paper only. The name and address, or pseudonym, of the competitor must be on each entry and...

Page 20

Russian History

The Spectator

The History of Russia. By V. 0. Kluchevsky. Translated by C. J. Hogarth. Vol. 5. (Dent. les.) PROFESSOR KLITCREVSKVS History of Russia, made out of lectures delivered at the...

Foch

The Spectator

Foch : The Man of Orleans. By B. H. Liddell Hart. (Eyre and Spottiawoode. 21s.) IN this weighty piece of historical analysis, the most serious and objective work which Captain...

Page 21

The Duke of Wellington

The Spectator

The Duke. By Philip Guedalla. (Hodder and Stoughton. 25s.) TILE Duke of Wellington's career affords an excellent example of that dictum of Disraeli's that " in order to rule...

Page 22

What Education Means Education. By T. Raymont. (Longmans. 7s. 6d.)

The Spectator

The Gateways of Learning. By Margaret Drummond. (Univer- sity of London Press. 6s.) WHEN the history of education in the early part of the twentieth century comes to be...

Old and New Moore

The Spectator

TuaouGnotrr his long life Mr. Moore has been occupied with a problem that has no general solution. It can be answered only here and there, according to particular circumstances,...

Page 23

Saints and Su - fis Studies in Early Mysticism in the Near

The Spectator

and Middle East. By Margaret Smith, M.A., Ph.D. (Sheldon Press. 12s. 6d.) WE are already indebted to Dr. Margaret Smith for her admirable monograph on the mystic 'tibia. In her...

International Illumination

The Spectator

The Unity of the World. By Cuglielmo Ferrero. Translated by Howard Coxe. (Cape. 5s.) World Champions. By Paul Morand. Translated by Hamish Miles. (Heinemann. 7s. 6d.) DR....

Page 24

Native Dietaries

The Spectator

Tins report, prepared jointly by the Director of the Rowett Research Institute and the Director of Medical Services in Kenya and issued by the Medical Research Council, is of...

. Dnixer subscribers who arc changing their addresses pre asked

The Spectator

to notify the SPECTATOR Office BEFORE MIDDAY. on MONDAY ' or EACH WEEK. The 'previous address to which the paper has been sent and receipt reference number should be geode.

Page 25

The " Thunderer "

The Spectator

The Story of " The Times." By William Dodgson Bowman. (Routledge. 12s. 6d.) NEARLY a century and a half ago, on January 1st, 1783, a shrewd. bookseller and printer named John...

This Way to Parnassus

The Spectator

2s. 6d.) SOME will have it that this is a lean season for the English Muse, a period which will seem to posterity devoid alike of great poets and great poetry. That may or may...

Page 26

Fiction

The Spectator

A Diversity of Creatures Sarah Gay. By Mary Borden. (Heinemann. 7s. 6d.) Wanton Ways. By Norah C. James. (Duckworth. 7s. 6d.) WHEN so many excellent novels are being written,...

Three Historical Novels

The Spectator

with her Greek and Roman stories have modified the attitude of many modern readers to the historical novel, but there are some people who still like the escape which the...

Page 28

THE DARK DUTY. By Margaret Wilson. (Cape. 7s. 6d.)—This is

The Spectator

a propaganda novel, and a good one. Its subject is capital punishment. Wisely, Miss Wilson concen- trates not on the condemned man but on those who have to carry out the...

New Novels

The Spectator

CATHERINE JOINS UP. By Adrienne Thomas. (Elkin Mathews. 7s. 6d.).—The pity and terror of the War seen by a young girl of Lorraine. Catherine Lentz under- took the most...

DARK MOUNTAIN. By David Hogan. (Shaylor. 5s.)— The guerilla warfare

The Spectator

waged by the Sinn Feiners against the Black-and-Tans is a romantic and sensational theme, and the author makes the most of it in this vigorous series of short stories.

THE GREATEST OF THESE (by Nikolai Gubsky : Elkin Mathews

The Spectator

and Marrot, 7s. 6d.) is the story of a Russian family on the eve of the War. The characters—the innocent-passionate heroine, her matter-of-fact sisters, her rake of a father,...

THE VALE OF MAENALUS. By Alice Buchan. (Bern. 7s. 6d.)—A

The Spectator

sincere and careful study of three ineffectual young people making love by quotation and trying to straighten out their emotional tangles. With her last breath the heroine is...

EAST WIND WEST WIND. By Pearl S. Buck. (Methuen. 7s.

The Spectator

6d.)—The authoress of The Good Earth gives us another intimate tale of Chinese life skilfully blended, for the taste of the Western reader, with Anglo-Saxon sentiment....

MAD PUPPETSTOWN. By M. J. Farrell. (Collins. 7s. 6d.) —Another

The Spectator

charming book about an Anglo-Irish childhood before the " troubles." More vivid in its Irish atmosphere and detail than in the English.

DAVID BETTERTON. By His Honour Judge Ruegg. (Daniel. 7s. 6d.)—Blackest

The Spectator

blackmail is the mainspring of the plot ; the villains are " so-called Socialists " ; the sun is facetiously referred to as " Sol " ; and the hero dreams of Queen Mab and the...

Page 30

A Challenge to Neurasthenia (Williams and Norgate, is. 6d.) is

The Spectator

written by, and from the point of view of, a patient suffering from the disease which she discusses. Miss Armitage, whose name appears only on the last page, here gives an...

A thoughtful little book is the Universities in Great Britain

The Spectator

: their Position and their Problems, by Professor Ernest Barker (Student Christian Movement Press, 3s. 6d.), and deserves to be widely read. Professor Barker, an Oxford man who...

Books about Rousseau have fallen on us of late as

The Spectator

thick as autumnal leaves in Vallombrosa ; and Mr. John Charpentier is a bold man to add yet another to the pile. Rousseau : the Child of Nature (Methuen, 15s.) is, however, a...

Sir Herbert Wilkins has returned from his Arctic voyage by

The Spectator

submarine, and presumably will soon give a full account of the adventure. What he proposed to do, his methods and his companions are described in advance in Under the North Pole...

Current Literature

The Spectator

Tins country has to thank General Sir Charles Monro, a scion of a well-known Scottish family, for three things. He was among the first founders of modem infantry fire tactics,...

Those who would appraise the Indian ferment in its true

The Spectator

dimensions cannot do better than read a little book which sets forth the conclusions of Christa Seva Sangha, a com- munity of Englishmen and Indians wedded to Indian customs and...

* * * * The special autumn number of The

The Spectator

Studio, published at 7s. 6d., is this year devoted to Modern Photography. By modem " photography, Mr. G. H. Saxion means photo- graphy whose aim is partly or wholly aesthetic...

The literary reputation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle has been

The Spectator

somewhat obscured by the activities of his later public life. Engaging, with characteristic integrity and force, upon a fresh career in controversial waters, he deliberately...

Page 32

FISCAL CONTROVERSIES.

The Spectator

The confusion of the contest, moreover, is likely to be intensified by the manner in which the whole fiscal controversy on Free Trade and Protection is being revived. The...

THE CITY'S VIEW.

The Spectator

I cannot help thinking, however, that in the present instance the view which is taken by the City of the forth- coming contest is the right one, and I want to set it out very...

Finance Public & Private A Momentous Election wmi all respect

The Spectator

to the great British public, one is inclined to wonder how far the enlargement of the franchise has contributed to a well-ordered judgement and decision with regard to such...

The Modern Home f We shall be pleased to reply

The Spectator

to any enquiries arising from the articles we publish on the Modern Home page. Enquiries should be addressed to the Editor, The SPECTATOR, 99 Gower Street, W .C. 1, with "...

CONFUSED ISSUES.

The Spectator

Moreover, the difficulty of the electors will not be relieved by the fact that it is already evident that in many respects the contest will be of the most confused character...

Page 34

PRECAUTIONARY MEASURES.

The Spectator

The directors of the Bank have taken carefully into con- sideration the effect of the exchange depreciation upon the capital of the bank, which is so largely employed in South...

PROOFS OF REPENTANCE.

The Spectator

Indeed,._there is little doubt that the situation at the Present moment would be even worse than it is but for the, fact that the National Government during its brief period of...

ANGLO-SOUTH AMERICAN BANK.

The Spectator

It was almost a foregone conclusion that in the case of all banks operating in South America, where the exchange, have so greatly depreciated in terms of sterling, that the...

BANKING IN JAPAN.

The Spectator

Although the trade depression which Japan and other countries is suffering has occasioned a reduction in the profits for the past half-year, the directors of the Yokohama Specie...

SOLVENCY OR BANKRUPTCY ?

The Spectator

Imagine, then, what would be the position if the public were now told that all these reforms =were a mere pretence, that expenditure was to rise still farther, that the Dole...

YEARS OF EXTRAVAGANCE.

The Spectator

Even during the heat of an election it is very important not to distort facts, and, therefore, in referring to the orgy of extravagance in National expenditure on the part of...

Too LATE.

The Spectator

• Instead of perceiving that the growth in unproductive expenditure ' and .the consequent increase in taxation constituted in themselves one of the chief causes of depression,...

Financial Notes

The Spectator

HOME STOCKS BETTER. THE stock markets are naturally dominated at the present time by election uncertainties. Or rather, it would, perhaps, be more correct to say by hopes of a...

Page 36

RUBBER.

The Spectator

It must not be supposed from the interesting address given by Mr. Eric Miller at the recent annual meeting of Harrisons and Crosfield that he was necessarily taking a rosy view...

RAPHAEL TUCK.

The Spectator

The Reports of Raphael Tuck and Sons Limited usually make a very consistently good showing, and for the past year, notwithstanding trade depression, the net profit, after...