1 FEBRUARY 1919

Page 1

The Admiralty will command the hearty approval of the nation

The Spectator

in its decision to give the officers and men of the Navy a temporary bonus as an instalment of the " just and equitable remuneration which their services so well merit." The...

There is no doubt, however, that this new Army scheme

The Spectator

makes a further inroad upon the plans of demobilization as they were originally conceived. The original plan was to release first the " pivotal " men and " slip " men—the men...

It is truly moat important news that the Anny is

The Spectator

to be better paid. In these days of transition and htotability thorn are two danger-points in the nation—the Army and the Police. What folly to underpay the two services on...

The Allied Peace Conference held its second plenary session last

The Spectator

Sanirlay. President Wilson - moved a resolution in favour of the establishment of a League of Nations as an essential and integral part of the Treaty of Peace. The world, he...

The Army manned under the new conditions will fill the

The Spectator

gap between now and the organization of a new voluntary standing Army. The right principle is to make a call upon those men who have given the shortest service, and that is what...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HE conditions prescribed by the Secretary for War for retaining enough men with the Colours for occupying Germany, for carrying on the work of the Army at home, and for...

President Wilson and the Allied Governments on Friday week issued

The Spectator

a warning to the small nations of Eastern Europe which are fighting for disputed territory, in accordance with the maxim that possession is nine pointa of the law. The Allies...

THE PAPER SHORTAGE.

The Spectator

TO OUR READERS. It is Mill necessary for readers to place a definite order for the " Spectator" with their Newsagent or at one of the Railway Bookstalls. Should any reader...

• ,,,• The Editor cannot accept responsibility for any articles

The Spectator

or letters submitted to him. but when stamped and addressed envelopes are sent he will do his best to return contributions in C686 of rejection.

Page 2

It is announced in the Times that the Belgian Government

The Spectator

have decided to preserve the ruins of Ypres as they stand. There could not have been a wiser decision. No one who has seen Ypree could possibly talk of rebuilding it. There is...

The nineteen small Powers represented at the Conference protested last

The Spectator

Saturday against the decision of the five large Powers to allow them only five seats in all ou each of the Com- mittees, except that dealing with reparation, while the large...

It is reported in Stockholm, according to the Times, that

The Spectator

the Bolshevik leaders Lenin and Trotsky have quarrelled, and that Lenin - favours a compromise with the respectable elements of society and with the Allies, while Trotsky wishes...

The Conference this week has debated the future destiny of

The Spectator

Germany's lost colonies. It is taken for granted that the colonies will not bo restored to the enemy, who treated the natives with true Prussian brutality. The unofficial...

Fresh strikes have occurred during the week in the engineering

The Spectator

and shipbuilding trades, especially in Glasgow, Belfast, and the Port of London. The Trade Union Executives, which recently agreed with the associated employers to introduce a...

Wo summarize below the facts about the prevalent industrial unrest

The Spectator

so far as we know them when we write on Thursday. The mark of all these strikes is that they are unofficial. They have not been sanctioned by the Trade Union Executives, but are...

What M. Sorel and the French Syndicalista called "direct action

The Spectator

" is the way of poverty, not the way of wealth. The less the wealth created—in other words, the less capital there la- the smaller the wages will be. The Trade Union...

The ruins of the ancient city will be a point

The Spectator

of pilgrimage for millions through successive generations, and incidentally the Belgians will derive the means of recouping themselves for many of the ravages of the war. It is...

There was still a war on at the end of

The Spectator

last week, when the Bol- sheviks of North Russia drove in some of the American unite operating from Archangel, where the Allies have both flanks resting on the coast. Shenkursk...

Page 3

The energetic company which has shown that disinterested management may

The Spectator

be applied with success to public-houses has changed its name from the Home Counties Public-House Trust to Trust Houses, Limited. It has also made a daring new move by taking...

It was appropriate that the dispersal of the victorious Grand

The Spectator

Fleet should be marked by the conferring upon Admiral Beatty of the freedom of Edinburgh. Mr. Kipling wrote, in a different context, many years ago :— " Far - called our...

The Canadian War Memorials Exhibition is perhaps the most interesting

The Spectator

collection of pictures that has been seen In London since the war. The selection is extraordinarily catholic, ranging from the late Mr. Byam . Shaw's hundred square feet of...

Forecasts have been published of the Government scheme for settling

The Spectator

soldiers on the land. It is proposed to settle soldiers in three different ways—on small-holdings, in cottages with an acre of land each, and on copartnership farms....

We rejoice to hear that on February 9th at 3

The Spectator

o'clock a memorial service for the late Mr. Roosevelt will be held in Westminster Abbey. Such a service will give the greatest possible satis- faction not only to the...

In Belfast the shipyard workers struck on Monday for a

The Spectator

forty- four-house week. The men employed in the municipal gas, electricity, and tramway undertakings ceased work also, and thus stopped many of the mills and factories, which...

The announcement of the completion of the new Ministry was

The Spectator

made in Tuesday's papers. Lord Lytton becomes Civil Lord of the Admiralty, Mr. C. A. McCurdy Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Food, Mr. James F. Hope Financial...

Perhaps the most striking quality in the Exhibition is rather

The Spectator

an unexpected one, for it is an effect of poignant realism. Nothing could be further removed from photographic ideals than moat of these pictures, and yet, whether we like it or...

As for the copartnership farms, they will be managed by

The Spectator

really expert farmers, so that no soldier who joins one of these farms will be backing his personal ability against fate. It is to be hoped that these farms, run by experts,...

Mr. Clynes, speaking on Friday week, attributed the labour unrest

The Spectator

to various causes—the reaction after the strain of war, the fear lest the return of peace should mean a reversal to lower wages and worse conditions, the high prices of food,...

Bank rate, 5 per cent., changed from fl per cent.

The Spectator

April 5, 1917.

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE CONFERENCE AT WORK. I T is good to know that the Allied Peace Conference has at last begun work in earnest. The troublesome question of procedure has been settled, and the...

UNIONISTS AND PARTITION.

The Spectator

T HE one fact above all others to which Unionists should always hold fast; and which they should make the basis of their ar&niment, is the fact that the Protestants and...

Page 6

THE WAR GRAVES.

The Spectator

I T is not without considerable hesitation that we have decided to write about the accepted decisions of the War Graves Commission. Nothing could put a harsher touch upon the...

Page 7

DEVELOPMENTS IN INDIA.

The Spectator

THE most interesting piece of news recently arrived from India is the statement that Mrs. Besant has been thrown over by the extremists whom previously she led. That is the...

Page 8

BOOK-TAKING.

The Spectator

V ERY few people are, or ever will be, " bookish." Though so many spend a great deal of time in reading, they do not read to gain either information or literary delight. They...

Page 9

THE BERLIN REVOLUTION OF 1818; A PERSONAL REMINISCENCE.

The Spectator

W HEN I was seven years old my father was appointed English Minister in Berlin and we went to Germany. This was in 1842. We went first to Cologne, where there was a great...

Page 10

CORRESPONDENCE.

The Spectator

RESTITUTION AND REPARATION IN BELGIUM. [To Tire Emma or um:" SPLOIAT011."] Sie, — German intellectuals have now taken up an attitude very different from that which they...

Page 11

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

[Letters of the length of one of our leading paragraphs are often more read, and therefore more effective, than those which fill treble the space.] THE WAR GRAVES. [To THE...

(To THE EDITOR or TEE SOE0TATOR.") Sea,—In the course of

The Spectator

your leading article under the above heading in your issue of January 25th you state that, with reference to the introduction of State Purchase in this country, "in April, 1915,...

A DRY AMERICA.

The Spectator

[To TM Easter or roe " SPECTLTOZ."] E112,—I feel very grateful to you, as do I think moat advocates of temperance, for your leading article upon " A Dry America." No more...

[To res EDITOR or vas " Semmes"]

The Spectator

Sia,—Referring to State ownership of public-houses, you write as follows "Everywhere the management of public-houses would be quite disinterested. The publican would be free...

[To THE EDITOR or THE SPECIATOR."3 and thousands of other

The Spectator

mothers whose eons have fallen in the war are pleading for a cross to be put up over their sone' graves—not the beautiful cross which most of 118, before we heard of the War...

Page 12

BOLSHEVISM.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR.") Sie,—The horror manifested by your Fabian correspondent at being connected with Bolshevism is highly amusing, but it is quite natural, for...

[To sHE EDITOR Or THE " SPECTATOR.") Sts,—Shortly after reading

The Spectator

your article on "A Dry America" I came across the following passage in The Note-Books of Samuel Butler (author. of Erewhon). Can it be denied that man's upward progression from...

Pro THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR."3

The Spectator

SIR,—Your excellent article on "A Dry America" touches warily on the probable correlation of drought and efficiency. But on the eve of our annual licensing meetings it may be...

INDEMNITIES.

The Spectator

(To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR.") Ste,—You speak eery kindly of my argument, but accuse me of ignoring an assumption. I reply that the assumption was none of mine, so that,...

(To THE EDITOR Or THE " SPECTATOR.")

The Spectator

Sin.—In his well-known Lectures on Subjects Connected with Diplomacy (1868), the late Professor Montague Bernard, Pro- fessor of International Law in the University of Oxford,...

Page 13

THE STATE AND THE FISHERMAN.

The Spectator

[To ran EDITOR or sat " Seterama."l Ste,—Iu the Spectator of January 11111 N. S. F. P. A."—the initials stand for the National Sea Fisheries Protection Associa- tion—is...

THE PRINKIPO CONFERENCE.

The Spectator

ITO roe EDITOR or ens " SPECTSPOS."1 Sts,—It is perfectly amazing to find the Spectator supporting the proposal that decent Russians should meet the Bolsheviks at a council...

Page 14

THE REV. WILLIAM KINGSLEY AND " RECONOGRAPHY."

The Spectator

(To THE Emma or ma "SIXOTATOIL"l Sta, — Your correspondent Mr. E. W. Naylor may like an endorsement of the view he expresses in his letter to you of January leth, to the...

INDIANS IN EAST AFRICA.

The Spectator

(To roe Burros or ens "Eiracrama.") Sta, — Your article in your issue of September 7th, which has only just arrived here, contains several statements which appear to call for...

"CLEARING OUT THE RUNS. "

The Spectator

(To THE Mares or THS SPECTATOR:1 Sea,—The Prime Minister, Mr. Boner Law, and our very latest Lord Chancellor have each in their several styles declared it to be the policy of...

Page 15

BUILDING OR RECONSTRUCTION ?

The Spectator

(To THE EDITOR or THE " 8PECTATOR."] Six,—The subject of cottage-building is one that engages the attention of most people on public bodies just now. I am much interested in...

THE FAMINE ABROAD.

The Spectator

(To THE Benoit or cm "13Ptell.S08.1 Sea,—In your recent article " A Dry America" occur words which arouse thought: "Nothing like this—no such self- imposed act of...

(To THE EDITOR. DT THE "SPECIATOR."1

The Spectator

Sen,—I think the principle the Rev. II. 0. Morgan and a previous correspondent approve—that it falls on landowners to provide fit cottages on their estates—is right; it is...

NELSON IN THE WEST INDIES.

The Spectator

LTo THE ED/TOR or THE " SPECTATOR") SIR, — Mr. Marston's letter on the above subject is of consider- able interest, as no details of the cutting out of the two American...

Page 16

A HOSPITAL FOR BRITISH SEAMEN AT MARSEILLES. (To THE EDITOR

The Spectator

or rot Srecuros."3 have such good reason to know the patriotism and generosity of your readers that I venture to appeal to them for a cause which I am sure they will not think...

THE BOYCOTT WEAPON.

The Spectator

(To THE EMTOP, Or one " Sezcmoa.") Sin,—We have seen little notice lately of this weapon as the one controlling and faultless power by the excretes of which the League of...

HEADMAN'S HILL.

The Spectator

Ito THE EDITOR or THE "SPECTATOR."] Rte.—"G. W. P.'s" paper on Deadman's Hill in Nidderdale is interesting, and the story of the murdered paekman is inane form or another well...

Page 17

BOOKS.

The Spectator

ABRAHAM LINCOLN.* MOTH lovers of Lincoln and of dramatic literature, we gladly welcome Mr. John Drinkwater's play, Abraham Lincoln, the latest addition to Lincoln literature,...

POETRY.

The Spectator

THE MIGHT-HAVE-BEEN. ' Emcee at sunset through the Sussex hills, I fancied, darkening their sky-line o'er, Came hordes of field-grey forms, with all the ills And horrors...

BROTHER SOCKDOLLOGER."

The Spectator

(To run EDIT02. Or TEE SPECTATOR.") SIR, —The above character was most likely related to the "Brother Blareaway " of our own time. In Mark Twain's Huckleberry Finn the...

NOTICE.—When "Correspondence" or Articles are signed sills the writer's name

The Spectator

or initial*, or wills a pseudonym, or are marked "Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode of...

Page 18

FREDERICK COURTENAY SELOUS.*

The Spectator

MR. JOHN G. Mn r-cre's memoir of his friend is so full and frank that the only notable omission is oil the more conspicuous. Salons was understood to have been the original of "...

Page 19

AMERICAN HISTORY.*

The Spectator

WWI sa Into:o- ld.. reel The late Mr. Cecil Chesterton, one of the many accomplished young men who paid with their lives for the Allied victory, spent his last leave in writing...

Page 20

BELIEF AND CREED.•

The Spectator

Tee controversy between Canon Glezebrook and the Bishop of Ely is not whether the dogmatic facts under discussion— the 'Virgin Birth of our Lord and His bodily Resurrection,...

Page 21

HAROLD TENNYSON, R.N.*

The Spectator

BORN in 1800, a son of Lord Tennyson, and grandma of the Poet Laureate, Harold Courtimay Tennyson was among the great company of brave men who died for Britain. Short as his...

BROWNING TO RUPERT BROOKE.* TUE time has long since gone

The Spectator

by in which it was necessary to say anything in rraise of the plan and execution of Irard'a English Poets. Like The Golden Treasury, it has passed out of the competition of...

Page 22

After the War. By Lord Esher. (J. Murray. 2s. ed.

The Spectator

net)— In this little book, addressed to Mr. Smillie as a political opponent, Lord Esher has set down his reflections on the Crown, the Church, the Cabinet, Parliament, and...

NEO-PLATONISM TO-DAY.* L*, the last of his stimulating lectures on

The Spectator

the philosophy of Plotinus,' Dean Inge takes a very gloomy view of the world situation which is confronting us to-day. " Civilization," he says, " lies prostrate, as a manias...

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

Patios in this column does nut memo* preeitule subsequent review.] Tirant to Blanch : a Study. By J. A. Vaeth. (H. Milford. 6s. 6d. net.)—Among Don Quixote's romances of...

Page 23

Two Years' Captivity in German East Africa. By Surgeon E.

The Spectator

C. Holtom, R.N. (Hutchinson. Os. 9d. net.)—When our warships bombarded Dar es Salaam in November, 1014, the author was sent to examine what purported to be a hospital ship....

Chosen Peoples. By Israel Zangwill. (Allen and Cowin. 28. net.)—This,

The Spectator

the first "Arthur Davis Memorial Lecture" before the Jewish Historical Society, is an eloquent refutation of an unnamed American's theory that " Germanism is Judaism." Mr....

University of Wisconsin Studies in Language and Literature. (Madison. $1.)—This

The Spectator

volume of essays by members of the Department of English in Wisconsin University.deals with a wide range of subjects from Beowulf to Henry James. " A History of Costuming on the...

A College Mystery. By A. P. Baker. (Cambridge: Helier. 3s.

The Spectator

6d. net.)--Some people say that they have seen a ghost in the Fellows' Garden at Christ's College. This ingenious little book purports to be the story of the old Fellow, named...

Conjectures on Original Composition. By Edward Young. Edited by Edith

The Spectator

J. Morley. (Manchester University Press and Longman. 4s. 6d. net.)—In the wonderful year 1759 Young addressed to Samuel Richardson his spirited defence of original composition...

The Turkish Problem. By Count Leon Ostrorog. Translated by Winifred

The Spectator

Stephens. (Chatto and Windus. 6s. net.)—This book was written in 1915 for French readers. Since then the fate of Turkey has been decided, but the author's vivacious account of...

The Cradle of the War. By H. Charles Woods. (P.

The Spectator

Murray. 12s. net)—This is an interesting account of the political and military position in the Balkans and Asiatic Turkey up to last summer. Though the complete victory of tho...

The Game of Diplomacy. By a European Diplomat (Hutchin- son-

The Spectator

108. 6d. net.)—M. E. de Scholking, the Russian journalist and diplomatist who is the author of this lively book, describes the foreign policy of the late Tsar and the men who...

A History of English Literature. By Arthur Compton- Rickett. (T.

The Spectator

C. and E. 0. Jack. Is. 6d. net.)—This is a spirited effort to relate the long history of our literature in a single volume of about seven hundred pages, printed in double...

Page 24

Palestine of the Jews. By Norman Bentwich. (Kogan Paul. 6s.

The Spectator

net.)—The author, who visited Palestine before the war and revisited it with the Egyptian Expeditionary Force, gives an encouraging accotuit of the numerous little Jewish...

Sea Fights of the (treat War. By W. L. Wyllie

The Spectator

and M. F. Wren (Cassell 12s. 61. net.)—This attractive book, well illustrated in colour and in black-and-white by Mr. Wylie and Mr. Bevan, contains descriptions of the naval...

Who's Who is America : 1918-19. Edited by A. N.

The Spectator

Marquis. (Stanley Paul. 30s. net.)—The tenth volume of this excellent biographical dictionary contains notices of 22,968 prominent men and women. Of these, 728 were born in...