16 MARCH 1962

Page 1

Snow, Leavis and the Two Cultures

The Spectator

the debate continues William Gerhardi J. D. Scott Dame Edith Sitwell Lord Boothby Stephen Toulmin G. S. Fraser Gavin Ewart anti others

Page 3

Portrait of the Week

The Spectator

THE SEVENTEEN - POWER DISARMAMENT CONFERENCE opened in Geneva, after informal talks between Lord Home (the British Foreign Secretary), Mr. Dean Rusk and Mr. Gromyko. The Soviet...

LA PRESENCE FRANcAISE

The Spectator

A s the Evian talks on the cease-fire in Algeria ..draw to a close,.and the uncertainty narroWs to a question of just how much bloodshed the OAS can bring about before peace is...

The Spectator

The Spectator

No. 6977 Established 1828 FRIDAY, MARCH 16, 1962

Page 4

Tests and Tactics

The Spectator

T ia Geneva disarmament conference has opened to the accompaniment of Mr. Gromyko's letter to U Thant and of more Russian activity in the Berlin air corridors. The proposals...

The Reluctant Apparatchiks

The Spectator

C OVIET agriculture is not faced with any new A./crisis. So far Mr. Khrushchev is right. It is simply in the same critical state that has afflicted it since 1930. There have...

We Know What We Like

The Spectator

Till: fuss about the Royal Academy's decision 1 to sell its Leonardo is, as these fusses usual]: am largely composed of cant. Particularly en joyable is the spectacle of the...

Page 5

The Price of Peace

The Spectator

S ow: letters we have received from supporters of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (couched for a welcome change in quiet and reasonable terms) ask us to say why we believe,...

A War Ending

The Spectator

From DARSIE GILLIE PARIS r i" HE seven-year Algerian war may be over when this is in print; a war without any battle above the level of a skirmish, a war that the French have...

Failure of Loyalty

The Spectator

T HE battle which has been carried on over Dr. Kroll, West German ambassador in Moscow, seems to have ended in a draw. On the one hand, Dr. Kroll is to be withdrawn from his...

Page 6

The Goldwater Show

The Spectator

From MURRAY KEMPTON NEW YORK T tlIS city remains the national centre for trade fairs. The annual appearances of United States Senator Barry Goldwater as em- bodiment of the...

Page 7

Oil and the French Economy

The Spectator

By RICHARD BAILEY I F the discussions on the possible entry of Britain into the Common Market have done nothing else they have made us much more aware of what goes on across the...

Page 9

SIR CHARLES SNOW, DR. F. R. LEAVIS, AND THE TWO

The Spectator

CULTURES The reaction to our publication last week of ihe full text of Dr. Leavis's Richmond lecture was quick and copious. We publish below a small sample. It will be...

Page 11

DAME EDITH SITWELL I read with an entire lack of

The Spectator

interest, but some surprise, Dr. F. R. Leavis's non-stop and male- volent attack on Sir Charles Snow in your last issue. I read to the end of this attack solely because I could...

J. D. SCOTT 'Strange, how desire doth outrun performance' —as

The Spectator

Beetle quoted after being flogged by Mr. King. C. P. Snow might quote with him: Dr. Leavis's stereotyped lunges of anti-Americanism, hi3 little bits of gossip, half-catty and...

LORD BOOTHBY It is fascinating to learn from Dr. Leavis

The Spectator

that he made T. S. Eliot a key figure, and D. H. Lawrence a great writer. In the Twenties some of us foolishly imagined that they did it for themselves. It would be interesting...

SUSAN HILL I feel that so many obvious flaws in

The Spectator

F. R. Leavis's lecture on C. P. Snow ought not to pass unnoticed. No doubt Leavis would apply a simi- lar sort of criticism to a student's essay. 1. Leavis values criticism as...

Page 12

DENIS LANT Dr. Leavis's lecture has had at least one

The Spectator

result which I don't think he can have intended. Without it I would certainly have thought C. P. Snow's picture of the pettiness, abuse and violence which could be found within...

STEPHEN TOULMIN The spectacle of the Sage of Downing pelting

The Spectator

C. P. Snow with coke is in itself merely undig- nified, and perhaps one should' ignore it. True: there is much in Dr. Leavis's Richmond Lecture to which even a third party can...

ANTHONY STORR Dr. Leavis's outburst against C. P. Snow will

The Spectator

surely evoke almost as many counter-attacks upon himself as would gratify him. I will there- fore confine myself to one small point. Dr. Leavis says: 'That he has really been a...

G. REICHARDT Had I been one of those invited to

The Spectator

attend Dr. Leavis's essay in self-expression, the point whereat my morale would have broken down was when he accused Sir Charles of 'repetitious- ness.' Thereafter, given a...

Page 13

GAVIN EWART When I was an undergraduate at Cambridge (1934-37)

The Spectator

Dr. Leavis was my English Super- visor, and I had rooms directly below Dr. Snow in Christ's College. Contrary to what one might expect, I found Dr. Snow (whom I knew socially...

G. 'S. FRASER Somebody might as well stick his neck

The Spectator

out. Dr. Leavis's lecture on C. P. Snow is one of thz greatest rhetorical performances I have ever read, for mounting splendour of scornful irony and of rage benignly laughing...

M. S. DEOL The myth of Snow, the great thinker,

The Spectator

is not the only one to reach us from Cambridge of late. There is also the myth of Leavis, the great critic. If one is the product of Sunday papers, the other is the creation of...

RONALD MILLAR Leavis on Snow is the boomerang of the

The Spectator

year. The splenetic doctor's attempt at professional assassination is so ludicrou , l!, overdone as to be laughable. The original leak of provocative snippets was full of...

SIR OLIVER SCOTT Mr. Leavis writes: 'But it is basic

The Spectator

cliché—more damagingly, for Snow's pretensions, cliché than the kind of thing I instanced first, for it dismisses the issue, tacitly eliminates the problem, discussion of which...

ARNOLD L. HASKELL Dr. Leavis's lecture, given its full text

The Spectator

in your last issue, is a demonstration of ill-mannered, self-centred and destructive adolescent behaviour that will surely be of interest to the psychologist. The whole lecture...

C. R. 0. JONES I have no special admiration for

The Spectator

Sir Charles Snow; but my reaction to DI. Leavis's lecture must have been shared by many. How can a man able to write: `The judgment I have to come out with is that not only is...

PETER JAI' A man may be ignorant of history and

The Spectator

slip- shod in his mode of expression, as C. P. Snow often is, and yet be able to state an important truth, while another may display vast learning and great powers of analysis,...

Page 15

Prof. Dr. M. J. Langeveld The Two Cultures? F. R.

The Spectator

Leavis Lady Chatterley's Lover The Warden of All Souls Nuclear Testing Peter Brown Love ol Liberty? L. M. Hopkins 'The Historical Novel' Martin Eve A Coldstream Painting Philip...

SIR.---1 read the Spectator as one of my sources of

The Spectator

information about England. I do not read it to be informed about Sweden. Quite a number of people wrote letters to tell Mr. Fennell that he was wrong and rude. Stir., I invite...

THE TWO CULTURES?

The Spectator

am told that my Richmond Lecture which you printed last week, may continue for a while to get some critical attention, so I shall be grateful if you will allow me to correct...

LADY CHATTERLEY'S LOVER

The Spectator

SIR. — In my Encounter article I put forward a certain interpretation of an episode in Lady Chatter ley's Lover. The main burden of Mr. Levin's criticism is that this...

Page 16

A COLDSTREAM PAINTING

The Spectator

SIR,—May I encroach on the hospitality of your columns to seek the whereabouts of a painting by William Coldstream called The Lion House painted in 1928. It was exhibited at the...

GEORGIAN BATH Sta,—During recent weeks considerable interest has been aroused

The Spectator

in No. 5 Beauford Square, the so- called 'Christmas card house,' which is threatened, with demolition to make way for a block of fiats. This Trust has endeavoured to speak for...

LOVE OF LIBERTY?

The Spectator

SIR,—Delegates to the Spanish trades union congress in Madrid heard General Franco deny dictatorship and affirm that 'we love liberty more than any other nation.' Will the...

'THE -HISTORICAL NOVEL'

The Spectator

SIR,—May I answer the question raised by your reviewer in the thoughtful and sympathetic notice of The Historical Novel? The reason why 'the first German edition of 1955 and our...

ECA DE QUEIROZ

The Spectator

SIR,—May I point out an unfortunate misstatement made by Miss Olivia Manning in her review of three novels under the heading Seducer in a Soutane in your issue of March 2, Miss...

NUCLEAR TESTING

The Spectator

SIR,—Those like Mr. R. A. Walker who are looking fOr a credible argument for the resumption of nuclear tests and who do not see the New York Times will be interested in the one...

CEREBRATION

The Spectator

SIR,—In your issue of March 9 Hugh Graham writes: 'More than any of the older artists represented in this show (Gris, Leger, Picasso, Klee, Miro) his [Jaques Villon's] aims...

THE WEN

The Spectator

Sta,—Believing implicitly as 1 do that (a) purely architecturally, London is one of the ugliest cities in the world; (b) 'the Metropolis' and 'Home Counties' are about the most...

Page 17

Records

The Spectator

Outward Bound By JOHN HALE IN contrast to their superb King Lear, the Marlowe Society's latest recordings, Henry V and • Cymbeline (Argo, four records each) will only be of...

Theatre

The Spectator

Lost Secret By BAMBER GASCOIGNE The Secret of the World. (Theatre Royal, Stratford E.) THE first act of Ted Allan's The Secret of the World is about a man called Sam Alexander...

Page 18

Television

The Spectator

Poor Old George By MORDECAI RICHLER Struck off, listed as a 'dramatised documentary' in the Radio Times, was neither drama nor documentary. It was a melodrama. Written by John...

Cinema

The Spectator

From the Chastity Belt By ISABEL QUICLY The Devil Never Sleeps. (Carl- ton.)—Walk on the Wild Side. (Columbia.) THIS was cliché-week in the cinema, making you wonder how...

Page 19

An Answer

The Spectator

Repair your struck senses Within the limit of memory. Return the strict laws And comparisons. Once let Shot nerve ends dictate A future and you've had it. Talk I not unwisely...

BOOKS

The Spectator

Hall of Fame By I H. PLUMB T HERE are still two nations, not so distinct now in clothes, accent and divergence of income as they were in Disraeli's day but still utterly...

Page 20

No Milk or Honey

The Spectator

A DECADE and a half can perhaps be re g arded n as the opportune time for one who was inti- mately concer ned with the epic of the sie g e of Jerusalem, in 1947-49, to sit down...

Horse-Collar Capitalism

The Spectator

RECENT work on the history of technolo g y has made it once more respectable to explain vast social chan g es in terms of specific inventions. It is true that we no lon g er...

Page 21

Strap-Hanging

The Spectator

'ONE night through the partition I overheard a conversation between my parents. . . . "The boy's mental development is somewhat lagging behind his physical one." "What?" cried...

Dear Diary

The Spectator

The Londoner. By Tudor Jenkins. (MacGibbon and Kee, 21 8.) IN the past five years there have been three Paul Tanfields, four Henry Fie'dings, four Penden- nises, four Atticuses,...

Page 22

Complete Historian

The Spectator

The French Revolution. By Georges Lefebvre. Translated by Elizabeth Moss Evanson. (Routledge and Kegan Paul, 35s.) ONE of the last papers ever given by Georges Lefebvre was...

Political Thriller

The Spectator

Ashes and Diamonds. By George Andrzeyevski. (Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 18s.) IN Poland the novel as we know it has never really been the dominant form. There are many reasons...

Page 23

Eighteenth-Century Pops

The Spectator

THIS is a reprint of a book first published in 1932, and anyone who has the faintest interest in the history of English literature and who missed it on its first appearance...

Not So Simple

The Spectator

The Foot of Clive. By John Berger. (Methuen, I8s.) SIMPLICITY, they used to tell me at school, is the greatest of the literary virtues. Never use a long word where a short one...

Page 24

Spring Fever in HP

The Spectator

By NICHOLAS DAVENPORT We all know how it started. In the middle of 1958 the then Chancellor (Mr. Amory) removed the restrictions upon bank lending and the joint stock banks...

Page 26

Investment Notes

The Spectator

By CUSTOS A LL those who disliked Mr. Chambers's ..aggressive take-over bidding will be de- lighted that ict only obtained 371 per cent. of COURTAULDS. In spite of the big...

Page 27

Thought for Food

The Spectator

Too Much Zeal By ELIZABETH DAVID SOME nine years ago, when I was contributing cookery articles to liar- per's Bazaar, I wrote a piece tlealing with the adaptation, to the cir-...

Company Notes

The Spectator

B RITISH AMERICAN TOBACCO produces a finely illustrated report for the year ended September 30, 1961, which has proved to be the best year in this great company's history. The...

Page 28

Consuming Interest

The Spectator

At Last By LESLIE ADRIAN THERE may be, as Falstaff believed, a divinity in odd numbers, but there is nothing but hell or expense in odd feet. In an age when `no one can think...

Page 29

Postscript • •

The Spectator

.0Nu, long ago, during the war, was acting number two for a time to the then London editor of the Manchester • Guardian. An agency message brought the news that Alan Moorehead...