7 APRIL 1961

Page 3

PRINTING AND THE PRESS

The Spectator

W E begin this week an important and wide- ranging survey of the British printing industry, and in particular of its effect on news- papers and magazines. The history of this...

No Answer

The Spectator

U NDER the slogan 'Hanging's no answer' the National Campaign for the Abolition of Capital Punishment is—as it announces on • another page of this issue—holding a mass meet- ing...

—Portrait of the Week

The Spectator

IT \VAS REGARDED as a matter for congratulation that as few as forty-four people were killed and 1,219 injured on the roads over the Easter week- end, TWO MARCHING COLUMNS of...

The Spectator

The Spectator

No. 6928 Established 1828 FRIDAY, APRIL 7, 1961

Page 4

Departure and Arrival

The Spectator

T uns week the Spectator has a new Literary Editor, Ronald Bryden : his writing on books will already be familiar to our readers. In warmly welcoming him, we part with sorrow...

Guilty Men

The Spectator

By KENNETH MACKENZIE f r HE result of the Treason Trial is a tremendous .1 victory for the banned African National Congress and its allies—and for sanity and tolerance—and a...

Page 5

Congress Dances

The Spectator

From SARAH GAINHAM VIENNA n RINCE METTERNICH would lift his aristocratic r nose if he could see the ballroom of the 'New' Hofburg and the new Congress of Vienna that is being...

Page 6

Gerhardi and the P.M.G.

The Spectator

By MICHAEL IVENS M ANY years ago I was describing to a friend a curious and, to me, perplexing psychical experience. `Why don't you have a word with William Gerhardi?' said my...

Page 8

The Elected Squares (3)

The Spectator

The White Americans By MORDECAI RICHLER ANADA, remember, is a two-headed culture. V./The French is protected by language, the English isn't. We English-speaking, but not neces-...

Page 11

The Case for the Unions

The Spectator

Needless to say, the unions do not leave these allegations unanswered--although some unions' officers are prepared to acknowledge, in the shadow of closures and rumours of...

Fleet Street

The Spectator

The biggest single grievance that the NPA have against the unions concerns restrictive practices designed—the NPA complains—to promote the feather-bedding of labour, and to...

PRINTING AND THE PRESS

The Spectator

By JOHN COLE How efficient is British printing? With newspapers closing or threatened with closure because their revenue cannot keep pace with rising production costs, it is an...

Page 12

The NPA

The Spectator

One is handicapped in judging the validity of such a defence by the cagey attitude of the NPA itself. When I asked one of its officers to discuss labour relations with me, he...

Labour Supply

The Spectator

Obviously, restrictive practices would not be possible if the unions did not exercise effective control over the supply of labour; and this brings us to what I regard as the...

Page 14

Craft Demarcation

The Spectator

Allegations about restrictive practices are not, of course, confined to Fleet Street. They arise also in general printing, out of what the em- ployers feel is the unions'...

Page 15

Stn,---Mr. Charles Brand's plea for better pay for well qualified

The Spectator

grammar school masters doing sixth- form work deserves support but I would suggest that the hardships and injustices which are the teachers' lot are not restricted to the men...

SIR,—IL is a pity that a journal of the Spectator's

The Spectator

standing should have published at the present time Mr. Charles Brand's article under such an all- embracing title as 'The Teacher's Lot.' Indeed, no one could say that as a...

S111,----110W very smug and parochial is Charles Brand's article 'The

The Spectator

Teacher'sLot'--- wire the gram- mar school masters! Has Mr. Brand ever been inside a secondary modern school, I wonder? Despite • first-class honours degree 1 chose to work in a...

The Teacher's Lot J. Bell, R. IV. L. Wood,

The Spectator

Sheila M. Brooks, Richard M. E. Henderson. Arthur Blackwell, Katharine Whitehorn, 'Secondary Modern Teacher,' H. R. Wills Books for Overseas Readers James C. Kennedy, Leslie...

Page 17

SIR,—Mr. Brand seems anxious to split the teaching profession into

The Spectator

a number of squabbling factions at a time when all teachers should be firmly united in an attempt to obtain a substantial increase in the basic scale. It is about time that...

SIR',—The Spectator would have more cause to feel ashamed of

The Spectator

setting up as booksellers if it did not receive so many letters from readers complaining of the inefficiency of bookshops—including one or two run by the signatories of last...

MILTON

The Spectator

SIR.—Affecting to feel more sorrow than anger, Dr. Leavis asserts that I labour to repress critical debate. This is false. On the particular issue of modern literary•history to...

Sta,—Where is the greater failure? With the grammar school-leaver, literate,

The Spectator

not too diffident, practised in the methods of argument and study, and, in a formal sense, better-educated than 90 per cent. of the popu- lation? Or with the dimmer secondary...

SIR,--Charles Brand says that because, as a teacher, he cares

The Spectator

about education, he cannot risk strike ac- tion lest Jones and Smith fail to pass their I I-plus; he suggests, however, that parents should strike by keeping their children home...

BOOKS FOR OVERSEAS READERS SIR,—Mr. Gordon Grimley and others, representa-

The Spectator

tives of 'fairly well-known bookshops,' have taken you to task because The Spectator Ltd. offer to obtain books for overseas readers. As booksellers their case would have been...

SIR,---I read Charles Brand's article. 'The Teacher's Lot,' and my

The Spectator

hackles rose at the tenor of his ,argu- ment, though I would echo many of his asides. Mr, Brand's article seeks to perpetuate the fallacy that the - really hard work in...

SOUTH AFRICA .

The Spectator

SIR,—May I, through your paper, express the grateful thanks of nearly half my white countrymen and some, at least, of our unconsulted non-whites. for the . kindness and...

Page 18

MATTERS OF LIFE AND DEATH Sta,--Mr. Richard Wollheim draws a

The Spectator

sharp•distinc- tion between what Mr. St. John-Stevas believes 'as a Catholic' and what he believes `as a liberal'; and it is as a liberal that he believes that 'the dictates of...

Cinema

The Spectator

0, 0, Antonio By ISABEL QUIGLY The World of Apu. (Academy.) — II bell' Antonio. (Paris Pull- man.)—Taste of Fear. (Warner.) Is it inverted racialism? A friend of mine came out...

is instructive to reflect that the tortuous - verbiage about

The Spectator

Milton, which hasiccently appeared in your columns, is the work of correSpondents who are either teachers of English. or professional critics, or both. Their dispute may or may...

WHY?

The Spectator

SIR,- - TwiCe in the last few weeks your TV critic has referred sarcastically to a certain BBC announcer. Your critic would appear to hold' the vievi , that because the...

Page 20

Theatre

The Spectator

Semi-Detached By BAMBER GASCOIGNE Much Ado About Noth- ing. (Stratford-upon- Avon.) — Sparrers Can't Sing. (Wynd- ham's.) Ir• Much Ado isn't funny, it's nothing. It lacks the...

Page 22

Television

The Spectator

Medium Drama By PETER FORSTER Houston is an admirable player who seems easier to cast than he actually is, and 1 am both sorry and glad that shortly after watching his...

Ballet

The Spectator

Poets and Peasants By CLIVE BARNES However it is the Soviet-style `democratic peoples' republics' who have really tuned the folk-dance troupe to the pitch of art, and im-...

Page 23

Opera

The Spectator

Comic Forbear By DAVID CAIRNS THE notion that Falstaff is a freak of style with . - out portent in Verdi's output was always a pretty rotten one. Now that Un Giorno di Regno...

Page 24

BOOKS

The Spectator

Signals From a Rotten Star B Y RONALD BRYDEN AST year, Philip Toynbee published an appeal L i in several weekly and Sunday newspapers for contributions to a symposium of...

Page 25

For Optimists

The Spectator

Science and Human Values. By J. Bronowski. (Hutchinson, 12s. 6d.) Is science 'mechanical' and 'amoral'? Are the values of scientists distinctively 'other' than, or alien to,...

Back to Worktown

The Spectator

Tom HARR1SSON is not one of the British institu- tions which have changed since 1937. He still has the same bounce, the same gusto and the same curiosity. Recently he managed to...

Page 26

Points, Particles and Percepts

The Spectator

The Relevance of Whitehead. Edited by Ivor Leclerc. (Allen and Unwin, 42s.) 'Tun true method of philosophical construction is to frame a scheme of ideas, the best that one can,...

Page 27

Rags and Tatters

The Spectator

HEttobo - rus was told in Egypt that the Pharaoh who built the Great Pyramid probably soon after 2600 BC was a wicked ruler who compelled the people `to labour, one and all, in...

Page 28

Asylum Annals

The Spectator

COMBINED Operations HQ was a military laboratory, an inter-service training establish- ment and, in the words of Earl Mountbatten, `the only lunatic asylum in the world run by...

The Wounded Surgeon

The Spectator

The Chapman Report. By Irving Wallace. (Barker, 18s.) Across the Water. By Michael Campbell. (Heinemann, 16s.) Kindred by Choice. By Goethe. (Calder, 15s.) THE only reason for...

Page 29

The Chancellor's Dilemma

The Spectator

By NICHOLAS DAVENPORT TURN, if you will, to our eco- nomic affairs at home. Have you ever seen such a frightening mess? The Statistical Office has chosen this odd moment to re-...

Page 30

Growing Pains in the U.S. Economy

The Spectator

By RICHARD BAILEY TN his message to Congress on the Economic 'Growth Programme Mr. Kennedy said the performance of the American economy over the past seven years had not been...

Page 31

Investment Notes

The Spectator

By CUSTOS T IIE markets opened firmly after the holidays and it seems that every financial writer has recommended buying before the trustees are let loose on the market by the...

Company Notes

The Spectator

T HE Earl of Derby, chairman of TWW, the independent Television contractors for South Wales and the West of England, advises excellent results for the past year. Net profits...

Page 32

Roundabout

The Spectator

Healthful Hall By KATHARINE WHITEHORN As soon as I arrived, I became, in the eyes of the staff, a patient. I had a consultation: my weight, reflexes and habits were made the...

Page 33

Mind and Body

The Spectator

Alien Admissions By JOHN LYDGATE It was an ancient observation that certain fevers never attacked twice. In the eighteenth century, Edward Jenner; a country doctor, ex- ploited...

Page 34

Consuming Interest

The Spectator

Junkets by Jet By LESLIE ADRIAN THE joys of flying by jet are mixed, I'm beginning to discover. It's fine to be told by the pilot that you are travelling at 557 miles an hour...

Postscript . .

The Spectator

WITHER'D is the garland of the war, the soldier's pole is fall'n or something. Caesar's apartments have been struck, as they say in the film studios, and they began on Cleo-...