25 NOVEMBER 1955

Page 3

THE SILVER RUSH

The Spectator

T HE National Union of Railwaymen is asking for a 10 per cent. wage increase; the Transport Salaried Staffs Association for 7f per Wit.; and if the footplatemen's union has not...

SPECTATOR

The Spectator

ESTABLISHED 1828 No. 6648 FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 25, 1955 PRICE 7d.

Page 4

Portrait of the Week

The Spectator

M M. BULGANIN and Khrushchev, that inseparable duo, have been visiting Mr. Nehru in New Delhi. Garlanded like oxen, the Russian leaders have admired the Taj Mahal and improved...

THE GERMAN ECONOMY PAUSES

The Spectator

By our German Correspondent Bonn. W ESTERN GERMANY, like Britain, is having to pause in the mad race for higher production, fatter wage-packets, more consumption and greater...

Page 5

Political Commentary

The Spectator

BY HENRY FAIRLIE . ir HE Government has put up a sad display on the Finance Bill. The technical absurdity of having to revive the Bill on Monday afternoon may seem of slight...

Page 6

Starting from Geneva

The Spectator

I N trying to explain Mr. Molotov's outspoken willingness to put himself in the wrong with the Germans over the unity of their country, it hardly seems enough to point to the...

TELL IT TO THE MARINES INTELLIGENCE

The Spectator

THE COCKLESHELL HEROES 6. . . the story is true and memorable . . . it is like many British war filmS, and unlike almost all the American speci- mens, in telling its story with...

Page 7

IN THE MATTER of Burgess and Maclean the good sense

The Spectator

of Ministers continues steadfastly to abandon them. Lord Read- ing, replying for the Government in the House of Lords debate on Tuesday, referred acidly to the people who had...

I HAVE just been reading in an American magazine an

The Spectator

article about the deplorable state of affairs in Britain by one of the young men, Mr. Kenneth Tynan, who wrote that letter to the Daily Express and who have been taken to task...

A Spectator's Notebook

The Spectator

IN MONDAY'S Daily Mail there began the publication of a series of articles on Sir Winston Churchill entitled 'Life Begins at 80.' The series is written by an American...

MONDAY'S Daily Mail announced : 'Tomorrow—His Homes : his family

The Spectator

and his animals.' It seems that by Tuesday the Daily Mail had lost confidence in the authenticity of Mr. Herald's account, for without a word of explanation the series was...

•

The Spectator

WHEN A sensational article appeared last Thursday attacking 'C' Division of the Metropolitan Police, Sir John Nott-Bower, their Commisiioner, and Sir Hugh Lucas-Tooth, the...

EVERY TIME I hear of political murders in Russia I

The Spectator

recall Yeats's bitter lines about those who sought to bring the world under a rule yet were 'but weasels fighting in a hole.' Of the two main figures in the latest batch of...

Here are some examples of Mr. Herald's inventions : 'His

The Spectator

valet, John, who accompanies him on all his trips, will invari- ably call him over the phone at 7 a.m. in the summer-time and 8 in winter-time.' Sir Winston has no valet called...

Page 8

The Tactics of Abolition

The Spectator

BY CHRISTOPHER HOLLIS NY Member can ask the leave of the House to present a Bill on any subject under the Ten-Minute Rule. He can make his speech and then it is open to one...

`Mr. Ben-Gurion's statements are thought to have clouded the point

The Spectator

of Sir Anthony Eden's initiative by attributing clarity to his suggestions about, the details of a territorial settlement where none was intended. . .'—The Times Diplomatic...

Page 9

The Canker in the Levant

The Spectator

BY CYRIL FALLS W HEN an evil lasts a long time we ought in theory to become more concerned about it. In practice, unless it affects our own interests clearly and closely, we...

Page 10

The Montagu Case

The Spectator

BY IAN GILMOUR AST year we were treated to the spectacle of some of the most reputable publishers in England placed in the dock at the Old Bailey charged with publishing obscene...

Page 13

City and Suburban

The Spectator

BY JOHN BETJEMAN L L of us who live in small towns, or even in large boroughs, will be cheered by the news from Rugby. Hitherto that town, like most places, has held its...

Page 14

Strix

The Spectator

The Other Oliver Edwards I T was bound to happen sooner or later. The advertisement in the Agony Column read : 'Oliver Edwards, of London- derry and Lisburn, formerly of...

Page 16

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

Cyprus Brigadier A. S. Parker French Electoral Law E. L. Mallalieu, QC, MP and others Undesirable Emigrants Roger Gray, J. M. Money The Name's the Same Isabel Quigly St. David's...

UNDESIRABLE EMIGRANTS Sta,—As Mr. Robert Kee seeks to defend the

The Spectator

twelve young men without having read their letter, and Mr. Lindsay Anderson fears that some of your readers who did not see it maY have been given a false idea of it, you maY...

The Spectator

FRENCH ELECTORAL LAW

The Spectator

SIR,—The BBC and some newspapers—maybe unintentionally—have been misleading the public by persistently referring to the present French electoral law as proportional...

Page 17

THE NAME'S THE SAME

The Spectator

SIR,—The Spectator did not reach me in Italy last week, so I missed Mr. Peter Forster's letter about my review of his novel. He has misunderstood me. When I wrote of his...

ENGLISH AS SHE IS WROTE

The Spectator

SIR, —May I add to the notices for foreign visitors to Italy, recorded by Mr. Betjeman in 'City and Suburban,' the following: 'Dames are requested to keep their heads vested...

SUPER-SUPERLATIVES

The Spectator

Sta,—Surely every schoolboy knows of the syn- theticsubstance laevolcucyttriglycyllaevoleuey.1- triglycyllaevoleucyloctaglycylglycine. — Yours JAMES WAT T Middlefield, Cu...

ST. DAVID'S COLLEGE, LAMPETER

The Spectator

SIR,—When Mr. Betjeman referred (Spectator, November 11) to the charms and anxieties of St. David's College, he did not mention the chief cause of the college's straits. Alone...

SPASTICS

The Spectator

SIR,—Thoughts arc now turning to Christmas, that great Festival of Giving, and all over the land advance plans are being made for family reunions and rejoicings. At this...

SIR,---The absence of any coherent argument, which distinguished Mr. Anderson's

The Spectator

reply to Mr'. Fairlie, has already been diagnosed by Mr. Fairlie. But a good deal has, magnani- mously, been left unsaid. Mr. Anderson describes himself and his co- signatories...

Page 18

Painting

The Spectator

THE LONDON GROUP BECAUSE the London Group- exhibition, whic h is being held in the Whitechapel Art Gallery is, this year, confined to members, there is an opportunity to...

Contemporary Arts

The Spectator

Theatre : Paris and London PARIS THEATRE 'A BIG religious gadget' must, at some time, be assembled by every self-respecting French dramatist. Anouilh did Joan of Arc, Monther-...

Opera

The Spectator

TANNIIXUSER (Covent Garden) WHEN Tannhauser was performed at Sadler's Wells by the Carl Rosa Company a few months ago, it was received, in spite of an inadequate performance,...

THE STRONG ARE LONELY. By Fritz Hochwalder. (Piccadilly.) IT is

The Spectator

not often that we see what is called a 'strong' situation on the London stage. Fritz Hochwaldcr's powerful melodrama about the fate of the Jesuit settlements in Paraguay was...

Page 20

Ballet

The Spectator

DANCERS: SPANISI1 AND INDIAN OF the few kinds of folk dance that can be transferred intact to the stage, Spanish de- mands a consistent brilliance, a relentless dex- terity and...

Cinema

The Spectator

LA STRADA. (Curzon.) —OH ROSAL1NDA! (Rialto.) --SIMON AND LAURA. (Gau- mont.) FOR some time now the Italian film industry has shown itself more willing to consider the...

Vie Opertator

The Spectator

NOVEMBER 7, 1830 SELF-DENIAL.—II is said that the Premier, on his entering on office, was offered, but de- clined, the ribbon of the Garter, conferred on the Duke of Bedford;...

Television

The Spectator

I'm do mathematician and am as aware as you are that 'statistics can be made to prove any- thing,' yet I feel I'm not alone in falling, every time, for BBC's Facts and Figures....

Page 21

THE CITY OF LONDON

The Spectator

WINDFALLS ... ... Ian Forrest DOWNSTREAM ... • Edward Fortescue THE SECRET CITY ... Jeremiah Ashe BANKS AND BUDGE TS • Nicholas Davenport FLEET STREET ... ... Gerard Fay...

Page 22

Windfalls

The Spectator

By IAN FORREST HEN I think 1'11 spend it after all,' my friend said. 'It seems to me that "small savings" are only for people with big incomes.' After listening to his problem,...

Page 24

The Secret City

The Spectator

By JEREMIAH ASHE F ROM the Lop of a boom it is possible to survey the shape of things to come. Let us therefore take the present opportunity to consider the long-term future of...

Page 26

Downstream

The Spectator

By EDWARD FORTESCUE T HE Thames is so familiar, so much a part of every- day life in London, that few Londoners realise the many uses to which its waters, fresh and saline, are...

Page 28

Banks and Budgets

The Spectator

By NICHOLAS DAVENPORT FTER the crises of 1947, 1949 and 1951, we should all be familiar with the nature of the trouble besetting our Yet the nature of our present troubles is...

Page 30

'Fleet Street

The Spectator

By GERARD FAY I F you take it simply as a thoroughfare and ignore the view of St. Paul's, there is nothing special about Fleet Street except for St. Bride's Church, which lies...

Page 34

BOOKS FOR CHILDREN

The Spectator

Children from Five to Ten ONE of the best of the new picture books for such children is a new sort of adventure story, Harriet and Her Harmonium. It is the discreetly...

Page 35

Fireside Stories

The Spectator

MINNOW ofi THE SAY. By A. Philippa Pearce. Illustrated by Edward Ardizzone. (O.U.P., 10s. 6d.) SUN SLOWER, SUN FASTER. By Meriol Trevor. Illustrated by Edward Ardizzone....

Page 36

Classics

The Spectator

MODERN FAIRY STORIES. Edited by R. L. Green. (Dent, I Is. 6d.) PEOPLE who must give presents to children this Christmas could do much worse than remember these five books. The...

History

The Spectator

QUEEN IN WAITING. By Norah Lofts. (Joseph, 12s. 6d.) THE MINSTREL KNIGHT. By Philip Rush. (Collins, 8s.- 6d.) VIKING'S DAWN. By Henry Treece. (Bodley Head, 9s. 6d.) IT should...

Page 38

For Older Boys

The Spectator

WHITE MAGIC. By J. M. Scott. (Methuen, 9s. 6d.) ToP SECRET. By Elinor M. Brent-Dyer. (Chambers, 6s.) THE Logi . GLACIER. By Showell Styles. (Hart-Davis, l ls. 6d.) THE STOLEN...

Page 40

Presents : Last Thoughts

The Spectator

CHILDREN today probably no longer aspire to professions as mundane as the engine driver's, but Science and Crime by Richard Harrison and Fire Fighting by Egon Larsen (Frederick...

Page 41

BOOKS

The Spectator

The Genius of Ovid BY REX WARNER T HE bimillennium of Ovid's birth falls in 1957 and we are encouraged by the publishers of Mr. Wilkinson's excellent study* 'to take stock of...

Page 43

Kippers and Champagne

The Spectator

HORATIO BorroMLEY. By Julian Symons. (Cresset Press, 21s.) HORATIO BOTTOMLEY'S motto was the classic dictum of W. C. Fields : 'Never give a sucker an even break.' There is no...

Page 44

Pullman's Progress

The Spectator

THE HUMAN AGE. By Wyndham Lewis. (Methuen, 30s.) This book, sequel to that ruthless, interminable, brilliant Punch- and-Judy show The Childermass, published in 1927, continues...

A Sunny View

The Spectator

MR. GORLEY Purr's twenty years' acquaintance with America has softened the piercing visitor's-squint that made Mr. Gorer's The Americans exhilarating and, to an American reader,...

Page 46

New Novels

The Spectator

SNOW ON THE PINE. By Macdonald Hull. (Hammond, 15s.) THE BLOW AT THE HEART. By Bernard Glemser. (Macdonald, 12s. 6d.) SOME readers will remember the closing scene of Long the...

Hobbits Complete

The Spectator

THE RETURN OF THE KING, being the Third Part of THE LORD OF THE RINGS. By J. R..12. Tolkien, (Allen and Unwin, 21s.) IT is eighteen years since Professor Tolkien wrote a...

Page 48

The winners of Crossword No. 860 are: Miss M. 13.

The Spectator

MORLFY, The ,,,d co 0 Carleton, Pontefract, Yorke., and Miss MARION GINONR. 131 Moog" - Way, Golders Green. NW II.

SPECTATOR CROSSWORD No. 862

The Spectator

ACROSS 1 It sounds a very noisy smack! (6) 4 This kind of habit is a hand-to-mouth business (8). 10 Apartment X (7). 11 Exponent of skilful piece-work (7). 12 Lay petered...

Other People's Purgatories

The Spectator

Competitors were invited to submit neat and witty definitions of purgatory for three of the following : a poet, a civil servant, a schoolteacher, a housewife, a TV celebrity, a...

It is always difficult to find Christin a ', cards bearing suitable

The Spectator

greetings. A prize o r 15 is offered for a message of goodwill ( . fi a s more than 100 words of prose or 12 11 . 1 1 ( of verse) suitable for use by a heavywelg i boxer, an...

Page 49

WINTER DAYS We experience touches of frost before we have

The Spectator

anything like a real frost which, when it comes, is something to kill the tender shoots in the sheltered corner, put the final touches to the fall of leaves and make one think...

Country Life

The Spectator

BY IAN NIALL WATCHING three crows stealing potatoes, I was amused again at their nerve. When a cat or a dog steals there is some sense of wrong- doing, but crows,...

WEED CUTTING Mr. H. S. Whitehead, of Sea House, Kessing-

The Spectator

land Beach, Lowestoft, sent me an implement he has invented for cutting weeds without the strain and backache involved in the unskilled use of a scythe, sickle or other tool...

Chess

The Spectator

WHITE, 7 men. BLACK, 6 men. WHITE to play and mate in two moves: solution next week. Stahlberg's Chess and Chess Masters (Bell, 12/6) gives a series of pen pictures of the...

PROTECTING BROCCOLI One of the timely things that can be

The Spectator

done in the vegetable gardep is the protection of cauliflowers by breaking suitable leaves over the 'heads of the plants. This can be followed by taking a quantity of soil from...

Page 50

COMPANY' NOTES

The Spectator

By C USTOS ALL things considered it is reassuring to find markets so firm when money is so short. One of the effects of the credit squeeze is, of course, to force companies...

THE SKELETON AT THE WAGE FEAST

The Spectator

By NICHOLAS DAVENPORT As far as the City is concerned, the debate on the autumn Budget is at an end. It is prepared to concede that Mr. Butler has done enough by way of...