21 MAY 1887

Page 1

The Crimea Bill drags on at a pace to which

The Spectator

even that of a snail would seem like a flash of lightning. Yesterday week, after three divisions and the rejection of innumerable amendments, the House got from the beginning of...

8 4 ,* The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in any

The Spectator

case.

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HE Goblet Ministry has fallen, ostensibly on a financial 1 question. It is supposed that the Chamber is desirous of ridding itself decorously of General Boulanger ; but the...

The Gladstonians carried on Wednesday the St. Austell Division of

The Spectator

Cornwall, vacated by the resignation of Mr. Borlase, a very strong Gladstonian. But whereas Mr. Borlase was so sure of his seat that it was not even contested in the interest of...

Mr. Morley presided at the Cobden Club dinner last Satur-

The Spectator

day, and began by disowning any intention of turning that dinner to account in a party sense by speculating on the view which Mr. Cobden, had he been living, would have taken of...

It is supposed that M. Grdvy will have greater trouble

The Spectator

than usual in forming an Administration. M. Clemenceau, the only untried leader of a party, still declines to take office, probably because he could not fulfil hie Colonial and...

The Spectator

Page 2

The Emperors of Germany and Austria are not to meet

The Spectator

at Gastein this year. The reason assigned is that the German Emperor's health will not allow of so long a railway journey ; but as the Austrian Emperor could reach any appointed...

The Empire grows, as it were, by its own volition.

The Spectator

Nobody that we know of wants Zululand, but we have had to annex that State. The heart of the Zulus went out of them with the fall of Ekowe, the Boers are perpetually stealing...

Mr. Morley's speech on the Free-trade Question,—as apart from the

The Spectator

question which he professed hie intention of not handling, though he did handle it in a sense which seems to us utterly misleading,—was in every way excellent. He showed that...

Sir George Trevelyan has made two speeches this week against

The Spectator

the Liberal Unionists for not making up their differ- ences with the Gladstonians,—the first to the Eighty Club on Monday night, the other to the Manchester Reform Club on...

There was a noteworthy discussion in the Lords on Tuesday,

The Spectator

on the new Irish Land Bill. A most important clause in that Bill places leaseholders under the operation of the Land Act of 1881. Lord Fitzgerald, Lord Selborne, the Duke of...

At a special general meeting of the Eighty Club on

The Spectator

Wednes- day, it was determined that " it is the duty of the Liberal Party to oppose the Irish Crimes Bill now before Parliament, and to maintain and enforce the policy of...

In the Manchester speech, Sir George Trevelyan added to the

The Spectator

Whig Pharieaism of the earlier speech a violent attack on the imputations now current against the Parnellites for their con- nection with the dynamiters and the party of...

Page 3

The curious negotiation between the Government of India and Mr.

The Spectator

Cook, which we mentioned in February, 1886, is now complete. The Government has been long annoyed by the excessive sufferings of its Massulman subjects while making pilgrimage...

air. W. O'Brien, editor of United Ireland, is not making

The Spectator

much of his campaign against the Viceroy of Canada. The citizens of Toronto, in an immense meeting, passed resolutions denouncing his conduct; but he persisted in visiting the...

At a dinner given at the Mansion House on Wednesday

The Spectator

to old Rugbeians, Lord Derby, Mr. Goschen, and Lord Justice Bowen had their say. Lord Derby complained of the House of Lords for not containing nearly as many Rugbeians as it...

Bank Rate, 2 per cent.

The Spectator

Consols were on Friday 1031 to 1031.

Mr. Goschen on Saturday, the 14th inst., was entertained by

The Spectator

the Cecil Club at a dinner in Willis's Rooms, and addressed the audience in a spirited speech, very badly reported. He said the strange political situation, with all old...

The "pit-brow women" of Lancashire, whose right to earn their

The Spectator

wages of 2s. a day has been threatened with legislative interference for the last two years, interviewed the Home Secretary on Tuesday. They declared that their work, which is...

We are to have a new coin, and a clumsy

The Spectator

coin it will be. By a proclamation dated May 13th, it is ordered that a silver double- florin, or fifth of a pound, shall be issued from the Mint, and shall be received as...

Page 4

THE FALL OF THE FRENCH MINISTRY.

The Spectator

T "public of Europe is probably right in attaching great importance to the overthrow of the Goblet Ministry in France. That overthrow involves the fate of General Boulanger, who...

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE ST. AUSTELL ELECTION. W E are very anxious not to overrate the importance of the very remarkable result of the election for the St. Austell Division of Cornwall. We do not...

Page 5

MR. GOSCHEN AND THE CONSERVATIVES.

The Spectator

B UT scanty justice has been done to Mr. Goschen's speech of Saturday, the 14th inst., at the dinner given him by the Cecil Club. Except in the Times, it can hardly be said to...

Page 6

SIR GEORGE TREVELYAN ON THE SITUATION.

The Spectator

SIR GEORGE TREVELYAN'S address at the Eighty Club IJ was a very effective speech for its purpose, and his speech at Manchester, though not so effective for that purpose, was...

Page 7

THE FOREIGNERS IN ENGLAND.

The Spectator

I T would be a curious incident in the history of English' industry if an anti-Semitic agitation broke out among English workmen ; but it is not entirely impossible. Certain...

Page 8

MB. STANHOPE'S BOLD INNOVATION.

The Spectator

W E have often complained of that curious provision of our Constitution which debars the House of Commons from hearing the men who could beet tell it what it wants to know. No...

Page 9

THE PRIVILEGE OF PETITION.

The Spectator

W HAT is the present value of the right of petitioning Parliament/ When weighed and measured, has it any value at all In the days before Reform, there was no question as to what...

Page 10

MR. BELL COX'S IMPRISONMENT.

The Spectator

S UPPOSING we had imprisoned in a felon's cell a Jew who insisted on putting on his hat during prayer, or a Christian who insisted on kneeling in any part of the Church service...

Page 11

THE GWALIOR " FIND."

The Spectator

T HE Government of India has discovered a treasure in Gwalior,—one of those immense " hoards " of money of which we so often bear, but which are so seldom visible in actual...

Page 12

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

MR. GLADSTONE'S HAMPSTEAD SPEECH. [To ran EDITOR OW 7/111 SPZOTLTOZ."3 Sta,—To all who value the scrupulous love of justice which animates the Spectator, it must be a grief to...

Page 13

ECONOMIC LEGISLATION IN SWITZERLAND.

The Spectator

[To 1112 EDITOR C. , "rallorrrox.-] Sra,—During a recent vacationin Switzerland, I became greatly interested in the many questions of social politics that are now being...

Page 14

THE NATIONAL DEBT.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or TEE Erigorms."] Sus,—I am sorry that in striving for conciseness I failed to- make my meaning. distinct. My point is this. So long as the appreciation of gold...

POLITICS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF LONDON. [To re. Emrez or

The Spectator

THE Bezerncat."] SIR,—I gather from your note in the Spectator referring to the friendly controversy which arose on Presentation Day between Lord Granville and Sir John Lubbock,...

• MONARCHY IN THE HOUSE OF COMMONS. [To TEN Rome

The Spectator

OP PRO "EirscrAmos."1 Stn,—Any of the forty-five Members in question who read it mist have been a good deal surprised at the innuendo contained in the current number of the...

Page 15

POETRY.

The Spectator

OXFORD TO LONDON. 0 FRIEND, who labouring for the State, With sittings early, sittings late, Dost gnaw thy soul with righteous anger At party violence, party hate: To see our...

ART.

The Spectator

THE ROYAL SOCIETY OF PAINTERS IN WATER- COLOURS. DECOND NOTICE.] MR. ALBERT GOODWIN'S work in the present exhibition is at once attractive and irritating. He sends five or six...

THE LATE DR. ROSS.

The Spectator

[To TITS EDITOR Or Tee EPROTATOlt." Sta,—A wish has been expressed by the personal friends of the late Alexander J. Ross, D.D., that some corporate form should be given to his...

Page 16

THE MILLET EXHIBITION.

The Spectator

00LE DES BEAUX ARTS, PARIS. Fon those who are at Paris this springtime for the purpose of seeing pictures, there is an exhibition which will well recompense them for the long...

Page 18

BOOKS.

The Spectator

MR. LECKY'S LAST VOLUMES.* [FIRST NOTICE.] Tun years covered by Mr. Lecky's last two volumes—the period from the close of the struggle with America to the outbreak of the war...

Page 19

MR. BESANT'S ROMANCE OF THE SEA.* Faom a grim and

The Spectator

sordid reality, relieved by romance, which formed the subject of his recent novel, Children of Gibeon, Mr. Besant has turned in the story now before us to a stern and wild...

Page 20

DANTE'S " DIVINA COMMEDIA."•

The Spectator

Ix is with surprise that we read in Father Bowden's preface to the excellent translation of Dr. Hettinger's essay on " the scope and value" of Dante's work, that the volume he...

Page 22

THE STORY OF A SOUL.* Tam little poem is one

The Spectator

which we ought to have reviewed before Easter, as it is obviously meant to. celebrate Easter- tide ; but we regret our delay the less that we cannot say that the prologue on...

Page 23

CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

Horse-Racing in France. By R. Black, M.A. (Sampson Low, Marston, Searle, and Rivington.)—There is nothing in the whole world more serious and bardness-like than sport. Hence it...

Stag-Hunting on Exmoor. By the Hon. J. Fortescno. (Chapman and

The Spectator

Hall.)—Mr. M. F. Bisset was Master of the Devon and Somerset Staghounds for more than a quarter of a century (he resigned the post in 1881). Daring that period he kept a record...

Virginia Caro/arum, 1625-1685. By Edward D. Neil. (J. Mansell's Sons,

The Spectator

Albany, N.Y.)—Much curious and interesting matter may be found in this volume, though not, it must be confessed, without some considerable labour. It is a small quarto of more...

About Money and other Things. By the Author of " John

The Spectator

Halifax, Gentleman." (Macmillan and Co.)—Here we have ten essays, the occasional work of many years, reprinted. Some are of the reflective kind, with a moral gently suggested....

The 3fammalia. By Oscar Schmidt. " The International Scientific Series."

The Spectator

(Megan Paul, Trench, and Co.)—The spread of paheon. tology has been so vast during the last quarter of a century, that had the great Cuvier, as Professor Schmidt soya, been...

Page 24

The Intermediate School Physical and Political Atlas (Stanford) is a

The Spectator

volume of a small quarto size, containing twenty-nine maps, for the excellence of which the publisher's name will be a sufficient guarantee. Europe, Asia, Africa, North and...

The Pre.History of the North. By the late Chamberlain J.

The Spectator

J. A. Woreaae. Translated by H. F. Morland Simpson. (Trithner and Co.)—Worsaae was a Danish archtoologiat (1821-1865), of great note in his country, and devoted his life to the...

Rhymes for the Young Folk. By William Allingham. (Cassell and

The Spectator

Co.)—All the children's good things are commonly crowded together at Christmas, when, to tell the truth, the " tasters " are so over. whelmed with work that they can hardly do...

A Treatise on Chemistry. By Sir H. E. Roscoe, F.H.B.,

The Spectator

and C. Bohorlemmer, F.H.B. " Organic Chemistry," Vol. III., Part III. (Macmillan and Co)—Part III. is devoted to the chemistry of the aromatic compounds ; this, by far the most...

Through a Microscope. By S. Wells, and others. (Interstate Pub-

The Spectator

lishing Company, Chicago.)—This is a useful little book, well calcu- lated to give learners an interest in natural science, and so enable them to employ with profit many hours...

The Labour of the Farm. By J. C. Morton. (Bradbury,

The Spectator

Agnew, and Co.)—This is one of the " Handbooks of the Farm " series, and, indeed, comes from the pen of its editor. Mr. Morton explains in his preface that it is virtually a new...

Familiar Trees. By G. S. Bonlger. First Series. (Cassell and

The Spectator

Co.)—Twenty kinds of trees are described, both scientifically and popularly, in this volume, and the description is illustrated by coloured plates. Not only is the general...

Health for the People. By Andrew Wilson. (Sampson Low and

The Spectator

Co.)—Dr. Andrew Wilson has collected here some forty essays first published in the journal which he edits, Health. He discourses on a great variety of topics—on mesmerism, for...

Physical Expression. By Francis Warner, M.D. " The International Scientific)

The Spectator

Series." (Kagan Paul, Trench, and Co.)—Such a subject as physical expression, which includes the pasture of the limbs, as well as that wonderful and complex assembly of various...

Training : a Tale of North-Country Life. By Margaret Jameson.

The Spectator

3 vole. (Tinsley Brothers.)—A " prefatory note," disclaiming literary skill, disarms criticism. It is quite true that Training is not "artistically finished." It is a simply...

Page 25

Baltimore and the 19th of April, 1861, by George William

The Spectator

Brown is a publication forming one of a series issued by the Johns Hopkins University. The author, Mr. Brown, was, in the eventful year which saw the outburst of Secession, the...

The British Empire. By Sir George Campbell, M.P. (Cassell and

The Spectator

Co.)—This ought to be a useful book to many a citizen who has been hitherto too inclined to leave to Ministers and bureaucrats the intricacies of moat Colonial questions, which...

PUBLICATIONS OF THE WEBS

The Spectator

_ 0 — Adams (G. M.). An Algonquin Maiden, cr era Al BerunFe India, Religion, &o., edited by li, /Mohan., Mu Albion, and othor Poems, 120. Birrell (A..). Ginter Dicta, Vol....

Page 26

The SPECTATOR can be had on Sunday mornings at Mn.

The Spectator

K. NILSSON'S, 212 Site de RivoU, Paris.

DEATH.

The Spectator

On the 16th inst., at Donbead St. Mary, Wilts, Emma Jen., widow of the late Rev. Thomas Warburton Dunston, HA., and eldest child of the late Robert Roscoe, Esq., and Martha, his...

The SPECTATOR is on Sale regularly at masses. CuPPLES, Trpaamt,

The Spectator

AND Co.'s, 283 Washington Street, Boston, Mast., U.S.A., where tingle Copies can be obtained, and Subscriptions are received.

Page 32

LONDON Printed by Joss CAMPBELL, of No. 1 Wellington Street,

The Spectator

in the Precinct of the Savoy, Strand, in the flonnty of Middlesex, at 18 Exeter Street, Strand ; and Published by him at th e srscrtros" OfIloe, No.1 Wellington Street, Strand....

Page 33

SPECIAL LITERARY SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

TO *prrtator No. 3,073.] FOR THE WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, MAY 21,1887.

Page 35

BOOKS.

The Spectator

A LOOK ROUND LITERATURE.* Ma. Bucamtert is a poet, and as such is entitled to attention when he enters the field of poetical criticism. Not that the critic's art is necessarily...

Literary OuppirmaIt•

The Spectator

LONDON: MAY 21, 1887.

Page 36

COLONEL RUSSELL'S MEMOIR OF LORD PETERBOROUGH.*

The Spectator

COLONEL RUSSELL was led, he tells us in his brief and manly preface, to write this memoir of Lord Peterborough for two reasons. The manuscript journal of Colonel de St. Pierre,...

Page 37

GEORGES BIZET.• In Bizet, as in Berlioz, Frenchmen have learnt

The Spectator

to feel a legiti- mate pride, largely tempered by remorse. Neither was able to extort full recognition from his countrymen during his life- time; but whilst Berlioz had at least...

Page 39

'nib HISTORY OF THE FACTORY SYSTEM.*

The Spectator

THE author of this very interesting book complains that " it is little less than a scandal to our industrial literature" that " there is absolutely no independent source of...

TRENCH AND BRUCE ON MIRACLES.*

The Spectator

Tut two books before us may be held to mark the change which has taken place in the discussion on the miraculous generally, and the miracles of Christianity in particular. When...

Page 41

VIRGIL IN OLD-FASHIONED BLANK VERSE.* CANON THORNHILL can hardly be

The Spectator

said to have carried out the principle of eclecticism which underlies the view advanced in his preface, to the effect that the best translation must be the outcome of all...

Page 42

THE COLONIAL OFFICE LIST.* Tag new edition of the Colonial

The Spectator

Office Lid, comprising a mass of historical, statistical, and official information respecting the British Colonial Dependencies, seems to have been very carefully revised...

Page 43

THE BOOB-FANCIER.•

The Spectator

BOOKS about books have of late been plentiful; but they have been written with different objects, and there is no competition between works like Mr. Frederic Harrison's and the...

Page 45

DR. BAERNBEITHER ON ENGLISH ASSOCIATIONS OF WORKING MEN.• Spice the

The Spectator

publication, in 1870, of Dr. Brentano's really great work, Die Arbeitergilden der Gegenwarr, the first serious study of Trade-Unions as an . important factor in contemporary...