17 APRIL 1971

Page 3

The Spectator

The Spectator

Established 1828 99 Gower Street, London WC1E 6AE Telephone: 01-387 3221 Telegrams Spectator, London Editor: George Gale Associate Editor: Michael Wynn Jones Literary Editor:...

Page 4

WAR CRIMES AND PUNISHMENT

The Spectator

The exercise of mercy is seldom to be questioned; but President Nixon's use of his prerogative after the judicial finding of Lieutenant galley's guilt is lamentable. The...

The Calley debate resumed: Henry Fairlie writes from Washington, D.C.

The Spectator

President Nixon's outrageous interferences in the legal processes of the trial of Lieuten- ant William Calley should overnight prevent any man of good will from ever again con-...

Page 6

POLITICAL COMMENTARY HUGH MACPHERSON

The Spectator

i 111111r nt um 9jardP*11 I III - =fa moll , .1!1111111■INI111111 1 111111111111111111111111' INITIM 1 111 4 M111 11111111113 11111 11 1111 111 !111 ! I I! 11111111q1111...

Page 7

August displeasure

The Spectator

Sir Solly Zuckerman's elevation was to be expected. I have been bemused for , everal years that a man of his age, whatever his earlier scientific expertise, should have re-...

Count me in

The Spectator

The instincts of the strip-teasing liberal bird who took off her sweaters one by one until she was down to a body stocking in order to protest against the Census may have been...

Scandalous immunity

The Spectator

One does not need to be a republican. however, to suggest that a more appropriate attitude for a Select Committee to adopt—and indeed for any Gracious Message to convey—would be...

Radical innovation

The Spectator

It is Mr Heath's choice of Robert Blake, the Provost of the Queen's College, Oxford. that I find quite the most interesting. Although actors and physicians and surgeons do...

A Royal Trust?

The Spectator

What surely is required is a decision as to which of the royal possessions are more pro- perly regarded as public property : and the maintenance of these, subject to public ac-...

A motley lot

The Spectator

As usual, the new Life Peers are a motley lot; but interesting for their illumination of 1 'mist do down to al(' sea again the manner of man the Prime Minister is. Two of the...

t:F ls t ttt t tt

The Spectator

THE SPECTATOR'S • NOTEBOOK _ The Queen's money is, naturally enough, a matter of great interest; and 1, for one, am delighted at Mr Heath's decision that the Queen should send...

Page 8

RELIGION

The Spectator

Marriage, Anglican style EDWARD NORMAN It is scarcely original to suppose that the institution of marriage is simply a human convention, as morally indifferent, in itself, as...

Page 9

WEST GERMANY—A SPECIAL REPORT

The Spectator

1. Tb e anb tbe ebantettor GEORGE VINE reports from Bonn The direction in which Britain's Prime Ministers usually head once they have received the seals of office is...

2.3m tett Pitbt4 _Onto

The Spectator

Chancellor Willy Brandt's Ostpolitik, like most offensives aimed at Moscow, peaceful or otherwise, got off to a flying start but is now inevitably bogged down to the axles in...

Page 10

In Or Aortt' Altrtin gbetto

The Spectator

FRANK WHITFORD It is in high summer that claustrophobia is most likely to strike. On weekends the three- lane city motorways are thick with cars rac- ing around the perimeter...

Page 11

The Quiet Revolution that already took place: Political Stability Economic

The Spectator

Prosperity Social Security THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY Issued by the German Embassy Press Department

Page 14

PERSONAL COLUMN

The Spectator

The battle of Igor Stravinsky CHARLES REID Overtaken by the sort of euphoria we naturally feel on shaking hands with a gen- ius who happens also to be History Ancient and...

Page 15

THE SPECTATOR REVIEWaBOOKS

The Spectator

Gabriel Pearson on Thomas Chatterton Auberon Waugh on Doris Lessing and Pearl Buck Other reviews by James Urmson; Jonathan Sumption, Peter Linehan, Jonathan Sale James Morris...

Page 16

PLACE A REGULAR ORDER FOR YOUR

The Spectator

Spectator 1111111. OMB IIIIIIIIIIIII SIM III= 1111 The Spectator, 99 Gower Street, London W.C71 11.1 I Please supply the Spectator for one year 0 I two years 0 I I Cheque...

Page 17

Gabriel Pearson on the life and death of Chatterton

The Spectator

The Complete Works of Thomas Chatterton: A Bicentenary Edition edited by Donald S. Taylor in association with Benjamin B. Hoover (ot.IP 2 vols £12.50) The actual, suffering,...

Page 18

Auberon Waugh on female novelists

The Spectator

Two lady novelists from the former colonies compete for our entertainment this week. To prefer one against the other might seem ungallant, and there is little to choose between...

James Urmson on morality

The Spectator

Morality and Moral Reasoning edited by John Casey (Methuen £2.50) The Object of Morality G. J. Warnock (Methuen Paperback 90p) Historically Cambridge philosophers have been of...

Page 19

Jonathan Sumption on Fascism

The Spectator

The Appeal of Fascism: a Study of Intollect- uals and Fascism, 19194945 Alastair Hamil- ton (Blond £3.00) In the writing of contemporary history, the cataclysmic events of...

Page 21

Jonathan Sale on comic art

The Spectator

Cartoons and Caricatures Bevis Hillier (Studio Vista/Dutton Pictureback 75p) Bevis Hillier is reasoned and fairly academic in his approach and presentation. He is not pedantic....

Peter Linehan on Spain in the 'thirties

The Spectator

The Republic and the Civil War in Spain edited by Raymond Carr (Macmillan £3.90) There can be few topics of recent history with a better claim to consideration by Macmillan's...

Page 22

Prize Crossword

The Spectator

A prize of £3 will be awarded for the first cor.. red t solution opened on 26 April. Address solu- tions: Crossword 1477, The Spectator, 99 Gower Street, London WCIE 6AE...

Solution to Crossword 1475. Across : 1 Screw- drivers 8

The Spectator

Seraskier 9 Dived 11 Infamy 12 Closures 14 Interacted 16 Loon 18 Also 19 Going Dutch 21 Inarable 22 Lenten 25 Greek 26 Echidnine 27 Stately homes. Down : 1 Serif 2 Rosemary 3...

COMPETITION

The Spectator

No. 646: Sweet Ambridge Set by Timothy Snow: In The Deserted Village Goldsmith immortalised the village preacher and the village schoolmaster. Competitors are asked to use...

No. 643: The winners

The Spectator

Charles Seaton reports: In his 'Notebook' some time ago the 'Spectator' accounted for T. S. Eliot's lines: Garlic and sapphires in the mud Clot the bedded axle-tree by...

Page 23

• ARTS • LETTERS • MONEY. LEISURE OPERA

The Spectator

For whom did you say? RODNEY MILNES Opera has no shortage of enemies (among them the editor of this weekly and Ken- neth Tynan are one ill-assorted pair), but When you look at...

Page 24

THEATRE

The Spectator

Museum piece KENNETH HURREN Our own National Theatre shoulders its responsibilities in this regard fairly consci- entiously, though without going out of its way to advertise...

TELEVISION

The Spectator

Kids' stuff Patrick SKENE CATLING Most of the time, chil- dren live more or less bravely in a land dom- inated by giants. In television land, how- ever, children seem superior...

Page 26

ART

The Spectator

Flagellation EVAN ANTHONY. and is venting a rather large amount of spleen against the anomalies of his country, using the American flag as his metaphor of protest. The ICA...

CINEMA

The Spectator

Heavyweights CHRISTOPHER HUDSON Most weeks fortunately produce one film to correct these wretched misapprehensions. This time it is The Great White Hope ('AA' Carlton), a very...

Page 27

Lemuel Gulliver's latest jottin g s.

The Spectator

Illustrated by David Austin.

Page 28

Orwell in Islington

The Spectator

Sir: Charles Harris (Letters, 3 April) is wrong in writing that George' Orwell 'discovered Isling- ton; he was the first of the middle- class intellectuals to settle in Can-...

Ulster Unionists

The Spectator

Sir: Surely it is Mr Cantwell (3 April) who is mistaken about the wishes of most Ulstermen not 'A Conservative' (27 March). The 'Handbook of the Ulster Question' published in...

On Waugh on Brown

The Spectator

Sir: In his critique of Lord Gcorge-B rown's Memoirs (27 March) Mr Auberon Waugh states that 'there is still a Foreign Office man in Bush House vetting over- seas broadcasts on...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

From Cameron Hazlehurst, Cyril Ray, Ian Harvey, Sarah Gainham and others. Historians at war Sir: The aim of Politicians at War, is to describe and explain the first stages of...

New Left, Old Right

The Spectator

Sir: An American familiar with New Left politics, I feel compelled to react to several misleading points made by Peregrine Worsthorne in his discussion of us politics (27...

Page 29

Politics of abortion

The Spectator

Sir: Mr Goodhart is right in his review of 'Abortion Law Re- formed' by Simms and Hindell (10 April). Truly, if you can convince 'a few hundred mrs' and demon- strate that...

Budget speeches

The Spectator

Sir: Hugh Macpherson (3 April) maintains that Budget speeches have made political reputations in the past, and he cites Gladstone's !Meech in 1853 and Lloyd George's In 1909 as...

Where women rule

The Spectator

Sir: Examples of matriarchal societies are not all that difficult to find and John Wain's state- ment (10 April) that 'we have re- cord of no society in which women hold more...

African education

The Spectator

Sir: I think only three comments are necessary on your article of 10 April, 'Rhodesia: Education for what?' by an unnamed correspon- dent. The first is that in southern Africa,...

Metric conspiracy

The Spectator

Sir: In his letter (3 April) Mr Pl eetwood-Hesketh did aim at the heart of the affair. Metrication, like other revolutionary matters of t° daY, comes upon us by stealth and then...

Sovereignty and the Common Market

The Spectator

Sir: Patricia MacLaughlin (10 April) tells us we should join the EEC because it is important and we could then influence its policies. If this is a valid reason for submitting...

Orphean answer

The Spectator

Sir: For a reason too well-known to need remark, I have only just read your Mr Palmer's piece (6 March). Two comments. I have tied a knot in my memory so that I may never...

Books wanted

The Spectator

Sir: I should like to thank you for your service in providing an op- portunity for subscribers and regu- lar readers to register their 'wants' in the 'Books Wanted' columns. In...

Delphian poser

The Spectator

Sir: I find myself a little confused. In your advertisements column the question is posed: 'Visiting London?' The answer to our prob- lems is, we are to stay at Dolphin Square...

The devil knows

The Spectator

Sir: Mr Simon Raven tells us (3 April) that 'we, with benefit of science, know that there is no devil'. Having speculated ruinously on the Grand National, may I, while thanking...

Page 30

MONEY The unreality of currency crises

The Spectator

NICHOLAS DAVENPORT While we have been bickering over the Budget strange things have been going on in the exchange markets. Dollar money has been pouring into Germany,...

JULIETTE'S WEEKLY FROLIC

The Spectator

Tantalum plucked me from the slippery road to ruin with a timely win at Worcester, while an Easter excursion to Chepstow proved profitable, though not, unfortunately, for my...

Page 31

SKINFLINT'S CITY DIARY

The Spectator

A lot of City folk, who are in the business of persuading the rest of us to trust them with our savings, have been saying in the Sunday papers, making their wishes father to...

Television remote control

The Spectator

Do you remember ten or twelve years ago it was usual, as it still is in the United States, for television shops to offer a remote control switch for channel selection and...

Ad epton

The Spectator

It is unthinkable that men like David Rowland of Fordham Investments are domiciled abroad just to save taxes, but a lot of people will never like them for it, even if it is only...

Donnelly and Berkeley and Melchett and Marsh

The Spectator

Desmond Donnelly and Humphry Berkeley are both nice men I like, but they have deci- ded in their different ways to become poli- tical April Ashleys. Once I put it to Hum- phry...

Clever fox

The Spectator

The economic folly and the paradox of the continuing struggle by the unions for what they call 'parity' and in the same breath what they call 'differentials' reminds me of a...

Page 32

PETER QUINCE

The Spectator

This fondness for the bells is partly because there is, to my mind, something satisfactory in the corporate voice of the village faithful declaring itself, at fixed points in...

DIARY OF THE YEAR

The Spectator

Tuesday 6 April: Mr Richard Marsh is to be- come chairman of British Rail in September. Six Welsh miners were killed in a gas blowout. Mr Paisley's birthday present from Mr...

CLIVE GAMMON

The Spectator

Anglophile friends abroad, going on as usual about the glories of the English pub, rarely fail to mention how much they love pub games. What they mean is lined, wise old faces...

Page 33

Pamela VANDYKE PRICE

The Spectator

It used to be that even quite learned persons would 'play trains' by planning journeys via the pages of railways time-tables. Can it. be that the ardours of travelling by rail,...

CITY LIFE c BENNY GREEN

The Spectator

It was an inspired idea to house the new Football Hall of Fame in that sad Cinder- ella of a thoroughfare,. Newman Street, that utterly pointless continuation of Cleveland...

Page 34

TONY PALMER

The Spectator

Spectator, One of the illusions engendered by living in central London is that the commercial cinema is in a tolerably healthy state. True, nearly 70 per cent of film...

Page 35

Spectator Hotel Guide

The Spectator

England CAMBRIDGESHIRE Garden House Hotel' *** CAMBRIDGE Cambridge 55491 Royal Cambridge Hotel'" CAMBRIDGE Cambridge 51631 CORNWALL Meudon Hotel*** NEAR FALMOUTH Mawnan Smith...