16 JANUARY 1971

Page 3

IRRELEVANCE OF SOCIALISM

The Spectator

It is no criticism of Mr Anthony Crosland, although it is of the Labour party, to say that he is the best theorist they have got. The Fabian Society has published a tract by...

The Spectator

The Spectator

Established 1828 99 Gower Street, LondonkWC1 Telephone: 01-387 3221 Telegrams: Spectator, London Editor: George Gale Associate Editor: Michael Wynn Jones Literary Editor:...

Page 4

COMMONWEALTH MORALISINGS

The Spectator

The Commonwealth, being an institution in no strong position to do anyone any harm, and being rather less incapable than the United Nations organisation, say, in doing in a very...

Page 5

POLITICAL COMMENTARY

The Spectator

HUGH MACPHERSON And now', said Baldwin to Lloyd George, 'they have caught you telling the truth.' Politicians are much more concerned about the way their activities are...

Page 6

THE DUTSCHKE AFFAIR

The Spectator

The rightness of indecision By 'a Conservative' The decision of the Dutschke Appeals Tribunal, coming as it does at the beginning of a university term, will provoke discussion...

DIARY OF THE YEAR

The Spectator

Wednesday 6 January: From Paris, the news that the us Secretary of Defence believes all American ground forces will be out of Vietnam by the end of the year, and that the us...

Page 7

VIEW FROM THE GALLERY

The Spectator

A Tremendously Important Person S ALLY VINCENT Little more than half the full complement of the House of Commons returned from its holiday to grace' the first day of the new...

Page 8

Murdoch longs

The Spectator

But what of the quid pro quo, the reciprocal deal long talked of which would compensate Associated Newspapers for the ignominious loss of the Daily Mail to the Daily Express, by...

THE SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

Never can Fleet Street have come to so sorry a pass. The faces are long and ready to bitch; the backs are padded against stabs: never has the place been further removed, meta-...

Hilton art

The Spectator

Our art critic, Mr Evan Anthony, who con- scientiously turns up at a great many more exhibitions than he can bring himself to write about, experienced an opening last week that...

Walker wills

The Spectator

The conviction grows that the evident need of our Minister for the Environment, Mr Peter Walker—who has already been not very nice about historic town centres—to demonstrate to...

Donald McLachlan

The Spectator

Had not Donald McLachlan been killed in a motoring accident in Scotland last week- end, we would have resumed soon the dis- tinguished commentary on the affairs of the press...

New Looks

The Spectator

This week's SPECTATOR welcomes as political corespondent Mr Hugh Macpherson, ex- draughtsman, ex-physicist, ex-chairman • of Glasgow University Labour Club, ex-politi- cal...

Page 10

The missing manuscript

The Spectator

The KGB is a tainted source, and the pro- venance of the document cannot but cast grave doubts upon its genuineness. Yet in itself this is no proof that the Khrushchev 'memoirs'...

A publishing mystery

The Spectator

Here is a document of the greatest im- . portance—yet the publishers have utterly and uncompromisingly refused to give any indication as to the source of the document, its...

Problems of provenance

The Spectator

The publication of the Khrushchev 'memoirs' raises a number of fundamental questions. Is the book authentic, and if so, to what degree? Is it what it purports to be, namely the...

Enter the KGB

The Spectator

Rumours of the KGB's involvement began to circulate at a fairly early stage, and soon the essential facts became known. The in- termediary between Time Inc and the KGB was Mr...

THE KHRUSHCHEV MEMOIRS

The Spectator

How the KGB fooled the West TIBOR SZAMUELY On 23 November 1970 the Times, with a suitable flourish of trumpets began a prob- ably unprecedented four-week serialisation of the...

Page 11

Good at forgetting

The Spectator

Nevertheless, even taking all these bizarre circumstances into account, it should still be possible to establish (a) whether Khrushchev really is the author of the fragments,...

A surfeit of lies

The Spectator

But even allowing for the selection and editing by the KGB, might there not remain some worthwhile facts concerning a country about which we know so little? The book does...

Page 12

To what purpose?

The Spectator

What, then, are these purposes? To begin with, the money must have come in quite useful : the USSR is short of foreign currency, and the KGB is involved in many expensive...

Scissors and paste

The Spectator

Now for the claim that these are Khrushchevi authentic reminiscences, an analysis of their style shows that hardly any—probably none—of these fragments were dictated by...

Page 13

SMOKING

The Spectator

How to kick it BENNY GREEN On the evening of 19 October last, at ten m inutes to ten, I placed a clean sheet of paper in the typewriter and lit a cigarette, my eight- eenth of...

A dream industry

The Spectator

ROGER BARNARD It is a depressing fact that the intellectual abstractions, critical analyses, muckraking exposes, and social indictments which are accounted 'knowledge' in our...

Page 14

PERSONAL COLUMN

The Spectator

Soccer report PATRICK MARNHAM The poster outside the church hall in Liver- pool made a..bold inquiry of every passer-by. `What would you do if Christ returned to- morrow?'...

Page 15

THE SPECTATOR

The Spectator

wre MEVIEWaBOOKS W. H. Auden on George Orwell—Thirty Years After Denis Donoghue on the Essays and Poetry of Allen Tate Brian Crozier on Hugh Thomas, Richard Cobb on French...

Page 16

John Holloway on George Gissing

The Spectator

It is a surprise to learn that, in about 1890, Gissing was sometimes bracketed with Hardy and Meredith, and the three were seen to- gether as the major novelists of the age. The...

Page 17

Richard Cobb on French conflicts

The Spectator

The four essays in this collection, introduced and concluded by Dr Zeldin. are all con- cerned with the 1850s and 1860s and have as a common theme the conflict between...

Patrick Cosgrave on political scientists

The Spectator

For the tough-minded, this is an hilariously funny book : for the pessimistic, it is a tract that will make them well-nigh suicidal. That is to say, it is a characteristic...

Page 18

W. H. Auden on George Orwell

The Spectator

The Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell edited by Sonia Orwell and Ian Angus (Penguin 4 vols lOs each) Aside from editorial matter, these volumes run to...

Page 20

Malcolm Budd • on responsible thought

The Spectator

An important part of our attitudes towards other people is determined by the way in which we think of their actions. We think of people as being responsible or not responsi- ble...

Denis Donoghue on Allen Tate

The Spectator

Essays of Four Decades Allen Tate (oup 42s) There is a moment in Allen Tate's novel, The Fathers, when the narrator, Lacy Buchan, says that people living in formal societies,...

Page 21

Dermot Fenlon on Spanish decline

The Spectator

The New Cambridge Modern History: Vol IV, The Decline of Spain and the Thirty Years War 1609-48159, ed. J. P. Cooper (CUP 80s) The seventeenth century was an age in which men...

Page 22

P. S. Squire

The Spectator

on secret police The Russian Secret Police Ronald Hingley (Hutchinson 60s) 'One must admit that our social existence is a sorry affair. This absence of public opinion, this...

Page 23

Brian Crozier on Hugh Thomas

The Spectator

The first thing the wondering purchaser is entitled to know about . this book is that it runs to nearYy 1,700 pages (about the size of Who's Who); and the second, that at seven...

Page 25

COMPETITION

The Spectator

No 639: Heave ho! Set by M. K. Cheesetnan: The Boat Show is with us again. Com- petitors arc asked to celebrate it with a sea shanty (not more than sixteen lines) for all...

LETTERS TO THE LITERARY • EDITOR

The Spectator

Siberian trip Sir: Tibor Szamuely (Letters 9 January) has not replied to the points 1 raised in criticising his review of Involuntary Journey to Siberia, attributed to Andrei...

Comic cuts

The Spectator

Sir : Like Mr Christopher Reekie I enjoyed Benny Green's article on boys' papers, but must enter a mild protest at the way in which two relative johnny-come-latelies as Strang...

Page 26

Auberon Waugh on new novels

The Spectator

A new novel by Edna O'Brien is something to which any regular novel reviewer looks forward with such eagerness that he must be careful to moderate his language on discov- ering...

Prize Crossword

The Spectator

No. 1464 JASON A prize of three guineas will be awarded for the first correct solution opened on 25 January Address solutions: Crossword 1464, The Spec- tator, 99 Gower Street,...

Solution to Crossword No. 1462. Across: 1 Bespeaks 5 Bad

The Spectator

egg 9 Leporine 10 Scheer 12 Eulogy 13 Semester 15 Adjutant bird 18 Comp- trollers 23 Atlantic 24 Assure 26 Becket 27 Fanlight 28 Estate 29 Coverage. Down: 1 Belted 2 Supply 3...

Page 27

Electronic getting together

The Spectator

PATRICK SKENE CATLING ON TELEVISION There are experts (please don't ask for their names; they are only code-symbols perforated on tape in memory banks)— there are experts who...

Page 28

CINEMA

The Spectator

Middle ground DAVID COHEN We keep hearing that there is a crisis in the film industry here and in America. Com- panies try desperately to repeat successes like Easy Rider,...

ART

The Spectator

London secession EVAN ANTHONY To avoid the obvious, the Royal Academy's Vienna Secession show (which I'll get around 7 to when the crowd clears), I made a London ,secession...

RECORDS

The Spectator

Party pieces RODNEY MILNES The second issue of Decca's mammoth re.4 cording of the complete Haydn Symphonies comprises Nos 57-64 (HDNE 23.26), works that stem, as did the...

Page 29

TONY PALMER

The Spectator

On 1 January the new divorce law came into effect. It abandons the old legal concept of one person' and one person alone being the guilty party responsible 'for the break- down...

Page 30

Drug on market

The Spectator

Sir: In my capacity as President of the Professional Hypnotherapists Centre I have enabled hundreds of people to permanently stop smok- ing. May I suggest that the Royal College...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

Letters from Liman Kogan, Brian Branston, the Gay Liberation Front, John C. Goss, Robert Con- quest, R. Emmet' Tyrrell Jr, Victor Seely. Letters to the Literary Editor are on...

Gay Liberation

The Spectator

Sir: Andrew Lumsden's piece on the Gay Liberation Front (2 January) dwelt too much on our relations with the press. It is quite true that we do not want to be sensationalised or...

Antisemitic origin

The Spectator

Sir: The charge of antisemitism against Arabs is frequently denied by arguing that Arabs themselves are semites and therefore can hardly be antisemitic. However, an examination...

Palmer Bash

The Spectator

Sir: Mr Tony Palmer's pre- occupation with the Underground leads him to ignore what is taking place on the surface. I refer to his claim that 'the communications men have re-...

A nice letter

The Spectator

Sir: Do you never receive coin- pliMentary letters? Does no one feel it proper to put pen to paper except in indignation, argument or disapprobation? Or is it simply that...

Sir: Adding to Mr H. R. Pelly's note of amusement

The Spectator

regarding Mr Tony Palmer's pompous attitude towards youth may I recall an item of similar interest as that attitude and doubtless, if amusement isn't enough, of sociological...

Sir: Your article 'The Drug on the Market' (9 January)

The Spectator

betrays in- credible naiveté. Can it be that the stubborn Englishman who ignores threats of death from the Royal College of Physicians will not risk a fine for his 'illegal'...

.Greek phlegm

The Spectator

Sir: It is surprising that Simon Raven (2 January) believes that he can make a valid assessment of the Greek regime after a week in Corfu and two days in Athens. As to the...

Page 31

Peace and piety

The Spectator

Sir: The Reverend J. L. Peace, (Letters, 26 December) in criticism of His Most Reverend Ramsey's politics, concludes by offering his own politics for Dr Ramsey to adopt and...

Elgar variations

The Spectator

Sir: Elgar's Caractacus. Mr Howes's rambling letter is the more horrify- ing for its very innocence: for it shows the attitudes I complained bf so deep-set as no longer to feel...

Savoy exuorts

The Spectator

Sir: In the controversy which has gone on over the control of the Savoy Hotel, one important fact seems to have been overlooked and that is the value of the Savoy group to...

Alternative to Powell

The Spectator

Sir: Having just read Mr Powell's essay (14 November) it occurs to me that' though he may be the most enlightened gadfly in the his- tory of the Western world he is the most...

Was Mozart rude?

The Spectator

Sir: I wonder if I might refer to a small matter which I think would be of interest to readers. As keen Mozartians, my wife and I are regular patrons of the monthly concerts of...

Page 32

MONEY Bank rate must fall

The Spectator

NICHOLAS DAVENPORT The great industrial nations of the West are cutting their bank rates and making money cheaper—all except Britain. Npt before it is time—in view of rising...

Page 33

Puff of smoke

The Spectator

Smoking Balance Sheet in the Sunday Times this week : Economy would save Millions Cost of treatment and prod- uction loss due to smoking illness Cost of fires due to smoking...

JULIETTE'S WEEKLY FROLIC

The Spectator

An 8 to 1 place with my alternative selection, The Laird, proved almost as profitable at £3, as an outright win on his 6 to 5 conqueror, Into View, and so with my gambling...

SKINFLINT'S CITY DIARY Hire purchase minutiae

The Spectator

Though hire purchase deposits have been the target of the Treasury for many years in controlling inflation I recently saw some American statistics which make the point, well...

London Weekend Television

The Spectator

No reply had been received to the letter addressed early last week by the SPECTATOR to head-in-the-air Mr Aidan Crawley pro- testing at the transfer by GEC of their share-...

LWT (Stop Press)

The Spectator

The following letter has been received from LWT as the SPECTATOR goes to press: My Chairman, Mr Aidan Crawley, has passed on to me your letter to him dated 5th January in which...

Page 34

:SPORTING LIFE CLIVE GAMMON

The Spectator

Glencoe, according to a small, silly poem by T. S. Eliot, is where 'the patient stag breeds for the rifle.' They seemed to be doing it for sheer pleasure when I saw them at it,...

Pamela VANDYKE PRICE

The Spectator

Gastronomy abounds in old wives' tales: cheese at bedtime gives you bad dreams, port and champagne at the same meal gives you a hangover, women shouldn't walk through mushroom...

Page 35

PETER QUINCE

The Spectator

For several months rumour, as passed around at Women's Institute meetings, gatherings in the bar at the Fox and Hounds, and similar village assemblies, has warned us that the...