Mr. Boner Law expressed surprise that the resolution had been
moved and that anyone should object to it. It was foolish to talk of the Prime Minister as going to Genoa to make political capital, for he was in fact " setting out on a dark and doubtful adventure." A Conference at which America was not repre- sented was terribly handicapped. Mr. Boner Law confessed that he did not wish to strengthen the Bolsheviks by giving them recognition de jure, and that he did not believe trade with a Communist Government to be possible. If Russia restored " civilized relationships " with other countries she should be recognized ; but deeds, not promises, must be the test. There was no need to be pessimistic. If the Budget reduced taxation, the home market would quickly revive. Mr. Bonar Law concluded by declaring that the Prime Minister, who had brought to success many seemingly hopeless enterprises during the War, might perhaps do the same at Genoa. The amendment was rejected by 379 votes to 84, and the motion was adopted by 372 votes to 94.