The following Lists will illustrate the immediate cause of the

Defeat of Ministers.

1. Members who voted for Ministers on the Second Reading, but opposed them on this Motion.. 15 2. Members who voted fur them on that occasion, but were absent on this— 9

24 3. Members who voted against Ministers on the Second Reading, but sup.

ported them on this occasion 8

Difference in the strength of Ministers, arising from the 1 .

defection of false friends ..

ENGLISH MEMBERS.

Acland, Sir T Devonshire Buck, L. W. Exeter Fans, J. is Oxfordshire Gladstone, T Qneenhorough Handley, T. W. Newark Keck, G. A.L Leicestershire Morgan, Sir C Monmouthshire Mundy, F. .. Derbyshire

I. MEMBERS WHO VOTED FOR DIINISTERS ON THE SECOND READING, BUT OPPOSED THEM ON THIS MOTION.

Palmer, it Berkshire

Patten, J. W Lancashire

Powlett, Lord W...., Barham Staunton, Sir 0. Ilrycsbary WELSH ME MBE RS.

Wood, T. Breconshire Wynn, Sir \V Denbighshire Wynn, C. W 3/ontyorneryshira

2. MEMBERS WHO VOTED ON TILE SECOND READING, BUT ABSENTED THEM- SELVES ON THIS DIVISION.

ENGLISH MEMBERS.

Baillie, H. B Rye Bruce, AI Dchester Cripps, J....... Cirencester Dugdale, D. S Warwickshire

Gerlies, Viscount Corktrmuuth

Wilson, Sir Robert Southwark

WELSH MEMBER.

Morgan, C. 31. R..... Brecon

IRISH MEMBERS.

Bernard, T. King's County

Boyle, Lord Cork

3. MEMBERS WOO VOTED AGAINST MINISTERS ON THE SECOND READING, BUT SUPPORTED THEM ON THIS OCCASION.

ENGLISH MEMBERS.

Euston, Earl of.... .. Bury St. Edmds.

Pelham, J. C... .... Shropshire Seymour, Lord Okehampton Warrender, Sir G Bonitos

SCOTCH MEMBER.

Duff, A Elgin

IRISH MEMBERS.

Bateson, Sir It. Londonderry Bruen, H Carlow County Knox, J. H. Newry