The Imperfect Gift. By Phyllis Bottome. (John Murray. 6s.)—It is
very difficult to find a novel which is good all through. The author's ideas and powers of expression too often appear to evaporate after some twenty chapters. The Imperfect Gift is a striking example of this rule, for the opening scenes are well written and the character of the heroine is full of promise. The reader will find the story com- pletely satisfactory until the moment comes when he is told what is the particular talent to which the heroine, Marjory Delamaine, is going to devote herself. This talent is dramatic, and Marjory goes on the stage, and finally marries a successful actor-manager. It is always very difficult for an author to convince you that a great artistic success can be achieved by the heroine, and it is almost impossible to take an interest in this particular actor-manager. But there is a great deal which is to be admired in the book. The opening scenes in Italy are delightful, the writing is good and careful, and the characters are definitely drawn. The Royal romance which happens to Marjory's beautiful sister Evelyn is less ridiculous than is generally the case, and its ultimate results reflect much credit on the author's common-sense. From the context it is probable that this actor-manager himself is alluded to in the title as "the imperfect gift." The description is a true one, for he is very imperfect indeed.
Previous page
